There are a lot of games to go through! We can make it a little easier if we share each other's games here.
You can't tell anyone, though, okay? :)
https://itch.io/jam/jamsepticeye/rate/3931492#post-14398693

I’d love for you to check my game out! https://fredbear123410.itch.io/oddity

Haha, sure! We'd love to play your game, and in return, you can try out game Dreamer's Dilemma! It's a light hearted beat-em-up game with tons of beautifully animated characters, creatures, and backgrounds! Made as a labor of love between me and my partner for my birthday, you're sure to have a favorite game by the end ;p Enjoy! 

https://itch.io/jam/jamsepticeye/rate/3937781

Hehe, okay ill keep this between us lol, Hope u like it

https://itch.io/jam/jamsepticeye/rate/3935559

would love to get some ratings! https://onyxprism.itch.io/darkest-deal

just eating then I will rate and review yours, please check mine out too! Will return the favour to anyone who reviews mine 

Petrifact:

https://itch.io/jam/jamsepticeye/rate/3937290

thank you! https://itch.io/jam/jamsepticeye/rate/3937269

I'll keep it a secret if you will ;)

Our game is called D.I.M.!  Checking yours out now :)!

https://itch.io/jam/jamsepticeye/rate/3933325

Heyo, our game is a rhythm based game about a real life composer who was lost to time. No spoilers!!

https://schrecklock.itch.io/cadenza

https://fionaraab.itch.io/the-anty-christ

I made The Anty-Christ, my first game, with my husband. I have no coding experience so this was a doozy of a feat for me. It's crazy how I've done nothing else every moment for the last few days and barely got something in.

Just finished your game and man, that artwork is stunning! I had a really good time playing! I'd love for you to check out my game if you get the chance, best of luck!

https://itch.io/jam/jamsepticeye/rate/3935859

Secret game thread, how ominous! Give our team's release a try, it's a really neat gothic puzzle platformer!
https://stormingangel.itch.io/deathbed

Oh boy, it's gonna take some time to get through these but I'm so down.

Remember, everyone, not a word! We wouldn't wanna bump up this thread and get people to share more awesome works. That'd be crazy!

I won't tell if you don't https://sticky-boot.itch.io/martyr-me

Let me drop this secretly without anyone noticing...
https://itch.io/jam/jamsepticeye/rate/3937917

Here is a game where your objective is to slay the frightful beast of Rodaberg!

https://tea-c-b.itch.io/1866

Psst, here's my little RPG Maker/Visual Novel game... Your secret game's safe with me...

https://memezanthology.itch.io/summoning-in-suburbia

Your secret's safe with us!

Here's ours, playing yours now!

https://itch.io/jam/jamsepticeye/rate/3936995

Hahaha I love this! I will give your game a review! can't wait to hear your feedback on ours if you get the time!! <3  https://itch.io/jam/jamsepticeye/rate/3933648

https://itch.io/jam/jamsepticeye/rate/3937647

I’d appreciate any input I can get from my submission since it is only my first game!

My game is a speedrunning game where you need to use death to advance and get the fastest time possible!

https://inferno-studios-dev.itch.io/reincarnage

We don't speak about it.
https://itch.io/jam/jamsepticeye/rate/3937319

https://schrecklock.itch.io/cadenza Would love for people to rate ours!!

Hey, if you'd like to hoard some goblins for sacrifice, have a go at ours! We'll have a go at yours (but secretly!)
https://asyaorlova.itch.io/orkforce-reduction

Yeah, makes sense!

https://pootata.itch.io/reap-sow

REAP&SOW is a simple simulation game of necessary evils.

I’ll be sure to check out your game as well!

We won't tell a soul.

Whisperwood by Valknut

Thank you for creating such a post! With so many submissions it really is hard to get some eyes on our own stuff specifically!
I'd be really happy if some of you guys could check my game out:
https://itch.io/jam/jamsepticeye/rate/3937928
It's a little platformer type game about dying and unlocking new outfits

I also found a cool horror game named Whisperwood, which really creeped me out, and I wouldn't haver found it if it wasn't for posts like these!
https://itch.io/jam/jamsepticeye/rate/3936620

I made a murder mystery type game and I crave ratings 

https://itch.io/jam/jamsepticeye/rate/3934967

don't worry I will keep it secret, heres mine Warping Wizards by MangoWorks

You have my word… I will take this to the grave… https://itch.io/jam/jamsepticeye/rate/3937552

Don't worry, it will be the secret story between the two of us https://itch.io/jam/jamsepticeye/rate/3927784

I'm so glad so many people wanna keep a secret. I'll keep going through the games here!

Here’s my game— I’d be really happy to see you playing it! Available for WebGL, Windows, Mac, and Linux. If you run into any issues, just let me know! Watch now on Youtube: Graverun Gameplay

I will try to rate everyone's games honestly. If you can, please do check out my first itchIO game jam game.. (Though I do make games on the side anyways) https://itch.io/jam/jamsepticeye/rate/3937116

Shhhh https://fernando-ferreira.itch.io/death

SSSHHHHHhhhhhhhhhh (gets progressively quieter) https://itch.io/jam/jamsepticeye/rate/3937908

https://digi-knight.itch.io/til-death-do-i-part

Your secret is safe with me!

As I go through these, feel free to leave your feedback on my team's game! Or I might spill our little secret >:)
https://itch.io/jam/jamsepticeye/rate/3931492#post-14398693

🤫 - https://itch.io/jam/jamsepticeye/rate/3937938 

We’d appreciate any and all feedback on our puzzle platformer, Ghoast!

https://ociabbey.itch.io/ghoast

Have fun! <3

https://wolfstarr22.itch.io/rest-in-possibility

pssst a little bird whispered in my ear that you should check out Abracadavers  whenever you have the time if you haven't yet (  o . o   )

https://itch.io/jam/jamsepticeye/rate/3938081

I'll test your game out in secret on stream should you wish to pop on by ^^  (if you're interested i can post link!)

Here's my game "Clean History", it's a comedy arcade shooter, where Death has given you an opportunity... to clean your history.

Cleaning the history will make sure this keep this secret ;)

https://itch.io/jam/jamsepticeye/rate/3937635