itch.io

thanks!

yeah I can see why that's confusing, you have to read the letter again

cool game!

Added a full screen button

Sorry, I think progress is reset when I upload new builds

Uploading a fix right now!

The extra skills should be on the left of the screwdriver.

I've also removed the side bar from the upgrades screen.

Oops, this is a bug!

Thanks for the report, uploading a fix right now

Steam page now live https://store.steampowered.com/app/4144990/Criticality/

There is a delete save button on the end scene. The full game will have a proper menu.

probably server problems. try the download version

just beat the game again and the option will reappear

yep

I've emailed itch to add more voting options for game jams, if enough people do it it might happen.

Vote queue is one of the options in the current system which does help spread the votes a bit, could get itch to add pairwise voting as another option

Cool! 

If you expand on the pick stuff up mechanics take a look at Mischief Makers, one of my favourite pick up and throw games.

also makes them easier to click on so evens out

plus they look goofy small next to large atoms

I like how their deaths are your opportunity lol

The combat is not very interesting, after the 2nd room I would have liked a better sword so I could 1 hit the basic enemies.

Throwing while moving and pressing E was a bit fiddly as well. Would have prefered left click to throw while holding a person.

Walking was a bit slow. In general if I get what the solution is and just doing it takes time then I'm getting bored. 

The best thing hollow knight 2 added was the sprint ability lol

The boss fight was pretty cool. Putting him on the hook was pretty funny lol

too many games to play during voting, saw this one recommended in a community post :)

Cool game. Love the crunchy graphics. 

Had to randomly guess a couple of the afflictions. Like one guy was stood still near the camera and it was somehow gluttony? A couple more hints would be appreciated. 

Love the console commands

Also probably because people who made a puzzle platformer will rate up other puzzle platformers so the most popular genre gets a leg up.

Yeah that deals with small sample randomness but trolls can still 1-star bomb.

I like the posts people make of their own favourites lists. They should just make that a mechanic.

no.1 for enjoyment for me

no.1 for music if there was an audio category 

Good game, the graphics were stellar and the atmosphere was creepy AF 

AAA quality work

Dang this is some AAA quality shit

GMTK game jam has both a public vote and he picks a couple as his personal favourites 

much harder to cheat the system with Pairwise voting and voting doesn't necessarily need to just be for jammers

Hey, cool game. Seems a bit unfair to upgrade the rover if you die. You just send up in a death spiral. Maybe include more methods to evade the rover like tossing rocks to distract it or kicking up some dust to obscure line of sight.

At the moment the best tactic is to pick smaller size and see through walls and just circle around the nearest rock.

EDIT got the laser gun and shot the rover and then the game crashed lol

Hey, got to this after the voting period but this is one helluva polished game, even the page style fits in!

I love the Grim Fandango vibes. I like how the boss incentivises you to make the most profit. 

If you were to expand on this game I'd love more ways to upsell your clients and a papers please style back story to tug you in the opposite direction so there's more reason to lose funds.

Also the game says the year is 1998 but it's got more of a 50's vibe.

Really good job *thumbs up*

Best styled game page in all of itch!

Yep, my thoughts exactly.

I did a post about alternate voting systems that might be better for fairness.

It's bound to happen with this kind of voting system but at least if you have a lot of votes it has little effect. 

Yeah I know, these are alternatives

Hey so lots of people complaining about the comments and voting system but no one talking about alternatives. 

The current star average system favours games with few votes. A game with 10 5-star rating beats a game with 100 ratings with 4.9 average. You can just get 10 friends or 10 alt accounts to win this way (above the median votes threshold). Similarly a great game can get hidden by a few 1 star ratings because of small sample randomness. 

Here's a couple ideas for alternatives to the 5 star average system. Feel free to add your own in the comments.

1) Advocacy voting 

• Instead of 5 stars system you click on the categories you think this game should win in
• Can vote for multiple games in multiple categories
• Could add more categories for things like best student game or best first game or made me laugh etc.
• Used to select the pope sometimes

2) Bayesian average 

• Instead of the current mean-average star rating. 
• Weights scores based on the number of votes 
• Games with fewer ratings are adjusted toward the global average.
• Add a minimum threshold of votes to get ranked. 
• Prevents games with few 5-star votes from topping the chart.
• Doesn't eliminate 1-star bombing
• Used by sites like IMDB for movie rankings.

3. Pairwise (Head-to-Head) Voting

• Voters see two random games (or from the games that they've played) and pick which one is better. 
• Repeat many times; ranks are computed via Elo or Bradley-Terry systems.
• Removes rating inflation bias.
  
• Easier for players, just “which did you prefer?”
• Builds a robust ranking with enough comparisons.
• Used in Ludum Dare’s “smart randomizer” for a while in testing phases.

4. Ranked-Choice / Borda Count

• Each voter ranks their favorite games (1st, 2nd, 3rd, etc.). Points are assigned (e.g., 1st = 5 pts, 2nd = 3 pts, 3rd = 1 pt), and totals determine winners.
• Can't down-vote to boost yourself

I like advocacy voting or pairwise head to head voting best. But option 1, 3 and 4 prevents the 1 star bombing trolls.

Thanks, your anti-fishing game was top 5 for me

Cool game! Wish I had gotten to it during the voting

You can add instructions for "honest feedback only please, don't hold back so I can improve"

Mostly people want to be polite and not get hurt feelings. Also the voting system encourages this behaviour.

Might be better to do a ranked system

Hey that's my game! +1 for Master of the necropolis

Your game had more votes than the 1st + 2nd + 3rd + 4th place winners put together. Definitely think games with more votes should get weighted more heavily in this game jam. To avoid small sample bias.