Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines

Is telling friends and family to raise my game rating cheating?

A topic by Guruhebat created Jan 11, 2021 Views: 717 Replies: 13
Viewing posts 1 to 5

Let's say I have 30+ friends and 12 family members, and I ask them to register on itch.io, then I told them to view and rate my game. My question is, is that cheating or not? If that consider being an illegal act against the system, then what happens to my game page? Thank you

(1 edit) (+1)

I don't think it is cheating as long as they rate the game fairly.

Edit: If they rate it 5 with the intention to increase the game score regardless of the merit that is "cheating".

It's more of something to keep my game title on the homepage of the free game page. Also on "New & Popular" section .

Admin (1 edit) (+3)

I would consider that cheating then, it sounds like you’re instructing them all to rate it positively in a way that you can “game” the ranking system and have your game sit above others. The point of our rating system is not to see who has the largest family.

Thanks

(1 edit)

Ooo... I see. The game that I promote to my friends is at the game jam and also in the voting period, and all of my friends and family were not in the game jam. So they're not in the position to rate my game, they're just giving the game comments. But, however, somehow the traffic kinda boost my game popularity so that it makes her (I mean the game) to be on the 1st row of the list on the game jam submissions list.

I also included my stats here, so we can see where the traffic coming in. 


 If that was considered to be a cheating activity, then I'm sorry and, I promise it won't happen again. But at least give me some advice on how to promote my game properly. Thank you.

(+1)

I think if playing and feedbacking suggestions without having a profile (e.g. messaging in another way of communication), sounds fair and wont increase votes in that case. Just its "played"-number and stats about where players found your game (reference to its prev. section on itch-page)

Moderator(+1)

From the Release Announcements board, there is this rule:

Trying to cheat the vote system is strictly prohibited. This includes, but is not limited to: creating fake accounts, asking others to create accounts to vote for you, publicly spamming vote requests. You will be banned from this board and your post will be removed!

I’m not sure if all rules are the same for game pages too, but for future reference it’s better to ask first if you are unsure.

I was just thinking, maybe if I round up some of the early audience for my game, my game title would be still on the "free" or maybe "new & popular" section of the homepage.

(1 edit)

Getting blocked by admin is not cool I guest.

(1 edit)

I'm not speaking for itch.io, but it seems to me that finding an early audience (and feedback) for your game from your circle of acquaintances is  just smart marketing and development. If you ask only for positive reviews and high ratings, I still wouldn't consider that cheating but I'd find it annoying (like how every Medium post ends with a request for a clap or every podcast ends with a request for a like and subscribe). On the other hand, if you pay for fictional reviews and ratings or get them from fake accounts, that's definitely cheating.

Edit: the way you phrased your original post doesn't sound like cheating but the topic title does.

(+1)

Ooo yeah, I didn't notice that...

(+2)

Loads of people have their first audiences among friends and family, and like technicat said, that is including and not limited to itch.io, as a matter of fact that is not even limited to software creation, but I guess with anything you do. And yes, a lot of people have their friends and family to upvote their content, and I guess that goes on all platforms. I agree that indeed paying for positive reviews is cheating, and that is becoming more and more of an issue on reviewing platforms in general, especially since these fake reviews quite often overshadow honest reviews.  One of the reasons why I want to be very picky on my review blogs on tumblr when I ever attract the attention of big parties with my reviews (I know dream on, dream away, but you never know. When it comes to people skyrocketing into fame, crazier things have happened), as I always want my reviews to be credible. But enough about me... In the end when it comes to game ratings and upvotes and view and that sort of thing, on most sites with many visitors you need quite a lot to get into the picture.  If 'family' is over 10K of people coming to itch all upvoting your stuff (even if they are all blood relatives) I guess it can get cheating, but I cannot imagine your family and friends are in that much numbers... or is it? Perhaps I'm jumping into conclusions... 😁

(+1)

It's just something that I had in mind to keep my game floating on the homepage list. But if I do have 10K family members, I'll run for the presidential election... XD

"But if I do have 10K family members, I'll run for the presidential election... XD"

🤣

This topic has been auto-archived and can no longer be posted in because there haven't been any posts in a while.