Thanks for sending the game link!
Positives:
Negatives:
Conclusion: It’s a shame that the game is so short and even more disappointing that the street segment didn’t make it in. The game ended quickly, but what was there was enjoyable. Thanks again for sharing your game—it was a pleasant experience.
I would also appreciate it if you would play our game https://itch.io/jam/scream-jam-2024/rate/3038320
Thanks for sending the game link!
Positives:
Negatives:
Conclusion: This is a cool game with a strong visual style, which is one of its best features. Initially, it feels like a horror game, but as you get more comfortable with the mechanics, it takes on a roguelike feel. It was a unique experience—thanks for the game!
Thank you for such a complete review!
Nice point about the text, I could definitely tweak the speed in the future, or even pause with a keypress or something!
Man that AI was rough to make haha I used Unity's pathfinding, but if I used as it is, it would always go straight to the player. So I tried to make it a little more "dumb" and chase the last seen locations instead. I guess it needs more playthoughs to balance this out with more players!
Yeah after the game was finished, the clunky movement was a bit of a side effect of the AI as well... I think it's possible to configure how close to a wall an AI agent is, I'll try that to see if it improves it :)
Oh the doors! Nice one, haven't thought about it! Thanks for the tip as well!
I would also appreciate it if you would play our game https://itch.io/jam/scream-jam-2024/rate/3038320
Thanks for sharing the game!
Positives:
Negatives:
Conclusion: It’s tough to provide a thorough review because the game is still very short and unfinished, but it looks promising. Thanks for the experience!
I would also appreciate it if you would play our game https://itch.io/jam/scream-jam-2024/rate/3038320
Hi! Thanks for sharing the game! Let me start with the positives.
Positives:
Negatives:
Conclusion: I’ll be honest, I didn’t enjoy the game. I don’t understand why third-person perspective was used in a horror game. It gives a full view of everything, making the game feel more like a narrative experience than an indie horror. You might be lacking experience, which I totally understand. Your game reminded me of LET ME BOOK from the same jam. I don’t want you to feel disheartened by my review but instead hope you’ll take these points as constructive feedback. Hopefully, you’ll bring your A-game in future jams! Either way, thank you for the game and for all the effort you put into it!
Here's my game: https://darkplayer-games.itch.io/a-night-on-halloween
I'll review your game as soon as I can. I'll probably review it by Sunday
Thank you for sharing the game! I'll start with the positives:
Positives:
Negatives:
Conclusion: The game has great art design and immersive elements that help draw the player into the experience. However, the 'maniac' aspect was missing, replaced only by a cheap jump scare. It felt like this ending was a quick solution to meet a tight deadline. If that's the case, it’s understandable. The choice with the candy was also a bit unclear to me—I wasn’t sure why it was there. Either way, thank you for making the game; it was enjoyable to play!
I would also appreciate it if you would play our game https://itch.io/jam/scream-jam-2024/rate/3038320
Thank you for sharing the game! I'll start with the positives:
Positives:
Negatives:
Conclusion: I enjoyed the game—it’s creepy, and the safe zone with the rat adds a fun, quirky element. It’d be great if the rat could perform some kind of dark ritual or cast a fireball to blast open a wall at the end. The humorous element with the rat should be emphasized, as well as the horror in the sewer catacombs. Adding extra mechanics, like those I suggested in the 'Negatives,' would only improve the game. I genuinely enjoyed it, thank you for making it!
https://itch.io/jam/scream-jam-2024/rate/3054822
A surreal on-rails shooter where misfiring kills you.
Thank you for sharing the game! I'll start with the positives.
Positives:
Negatives:
Conclusion: This is a small game with an intriguing and unsettling story. I enjoyed playing it and appreciated the minimal yet effective storytelling style. Unlike other games, it’s not heavy-handed; you provide just the right amount of information, which I truly value. Thank you for making this game—I loved it!
I would also appreciate it if you would play our game https://itch.io/jam/scream-jam-2024/rate/3038320
https://itch.io/jam/scream-jam-2024/rate/3044433 I'd love some feedback!
Hi! Thank you for sending the link to your game. You do know I write honest reviews, right? So, let’s start with the positives:
Negatives:
Conclusion: I’m not sure what kind of review you were expecting from me. It’s hard to even call this a game. The only thing that seems to be working is the opening scene. I even thought maybe I had a broken version of the game, so I downloaded the game from its page, but the experience was the same, with no updates. I read some other players’ comments, and they were also reporting performance issues, which you fixed, so that’s good. Overall, this feels like an odd, unfinished project. I hope I wasn’t too harsh, and that you won’t take my words personally. Thanks again for sending me the game!
Hey please check out our game! Hope you enjoy it!
https://itch.io/jam/scream-jam-2024/rate/3059211
Hi! Thank you for sending the link to your game! I’ll start with the positives:
Positives:
Negatives:
Conclusion: The game started off nicely, and I enjoyed the initial experience. It wasn’t overly challenging, but the portals made me stop and think about what was happening, which was fun. I’m uncertain about my suggestion to add visual effects to the portals; maybe adding some sound effects or a character comment would be enough. It would also help to mark that the passage on the staircase is blocked, possibly with a barrier or by having the statue move aside to reveal stairs leading down. The final scene with the monster needs a complete overhaul, and it would be nice to make better use of the environment. For instance, the player could climb towers to ring bells, damaging the monster with sound. This has more gameplay depth and logic than a monster that only moves when you’re not looking. Despite the negatives, the game is fun, and I enjoyed it. Thanks again for sharing your game!
Hi! Thank you for sending the link to your game! I’ll start with the positives:
Positives:
Negatives:
Conclusion: The game is short but cozy. With music, a clear story, and fewer bugs, it would be fantastic. As it stands, though, I still enjoyed it.
Questions:
thank you for the feedback, this helps a lot, let’s start:
now the questions:
1 - the “S” button was a left over from the damage system, i leave it there because i had no time to fix it, so it end up being a “unstuck duct tape measure”
2 - the second house I presume is the one at the top in the middle, it should be a shop to buy tools to help on your journey, but since there was no time to code that, I just left it there to remember me later to add the stuff.
3 - it’s a feature, if you die after getting any items you should just wake up in the bus, the bus will be a “hub area” once I make more maps
4 - So the story is my take on the brazillian version of the “sack man” story, you know the story of the guy who kidnap kids and puts then in a sack to eat their liver because back in the day ppl believed that eating liver from kids could cure tuberculosis… that one, in my version the girl you play is on a trip back home in one of the cross country roads, the bus end up having a problem and they needed to stop close to some small decadent brazillian village, there she finds who or what is attacking the village and the true reason behind the kidnappings.
the insects are pretty much a allegory to pests being in your way to slow your progress since you are in a rural zone, but the true enemy is the sack man
Hi! Thank you for sharing the link to your game.
Positives:
Negatives:
Conclusion: It’s a shame you couldn’t complete the game to the level you intended, but it’s still a very cool project with strong features and diverse mechanics. I hope you complete it after the game jam. Thanks again for the game!
I would appreciate it if you would also play our game
https://itch.io/jam/scream-jam-2024/rate/3038320
Hi! This is our game: https://itch.io/jam/scream-jam-2024/rate/3055135
We unfortunately made a very silly mistake last minute, causing our final submission version not to include any ending scenes. There is a Mega link to the fixed version at the bottom of our game description. It's also okay if you feel like we should be rated based on what we end up submitting. We shall own our mistakes.
I will give your game a try as soon as I get home tonight!
Hi! Thank you for sharing the link to your game! I’ll start with the positives:
Positives:
Negatives:
Conclusion: The game is exceptional and among the best in this game jam. It’s not particularly scary, but the plot follows the spirit of sci-fi horror, where there are no villains—just a dangerous, mysterious situation that the characters must navigate with skill and ingenuity. This game deserves to be developed fully and sold on Steam for $15-20. While playing, a few ideas came to mind that might interest you, so I’ve listed them separately.
Ideas:
That’s all from me. Thank you for sharing the game. I enjoyed the story and characters immensely, and I truly hope to see this game on Steam someday. If that happens, I’ll definitely buy it. Thanks for the game!
Thanks for such comprehensive and thoughtful feedback! The initial plan was indeed to have the player figure out solutions and guide the characters with many explorable rooms and events. Unfortunately, time didn't allow that. We do have the motivation to develop the game further into our initial vision (especially after your encouragement!), but it's hard to say for sure since we are both students. We will also definitely try the games you mentioned!
By the way, when trying your game, I couldn't find a way to detach the load after parking into the area, and I seemed to be stuck at that step. Did I miss something?
I hope you find the motivation to complete your game! I understand where you’re coming from. While we may not be students, each of us has a job, and taking projects to the finish line is certainly a challenge.
Regarding the cargo detachment: You’re actually doing everything right; it’s just that the trigger on the trailer is hard to find. You need to press 'C' or 'CTRL' to crouch and look more carefully for the detachment. It’s a bit unfortunate that we have to explain this to players since it’s clearly a flaw on our part, and it does affect the experience. But no worries, we’ll fix this bug after the jam. Thank you for playing our game!
I would also appreciate it if you would play our game https://itch.io/jam/scream-jam-2024/rate/3038320
Hello! This is my game!! Its a job interview horror game!! Week of the Interview by CorgiStudios
Hi! Thank you for sending the link to your game.
Positives:
Negatives:
Conclusion: The game is cool, but I found the last company too difficult, and I’m embarrassed to say I didn’t discover all the endings. I enjoyed the strange world you created, and I hope you continue to develop it in future games. Thanks for the game!
I would also appreciate it if you would play our game https://itch.io/jam/scream-jam-2024/rate/3038320
Honest and useful feedback is always appreciated. Here's our game, Camera Tenebris: https://itch.io/jam/scream-jam-2024/rate/3058287
I will take a look at your game as well!
Hi! Thank you for sending your game. I’ll start with the positives.
Positives:
Negatives:
Conclusion: The game is excellent, with interesting and rarely seen mechanics. The final segment with the boss could be made more challenging. It might be worth making the level design a bit more complex to make escaping from him harder. Thanks again for the game!
Thank you for the detailed feedback! The boss was meant to chase the player through the portal into the house, making the sequence longer and forcing the player to stun it with flashes/photographs. We had to cut about 50% of the content we planned to put in. And the player is not supposed to be as fast as he is in the jam build, I'm guessing someone made him faster for testing and forgot to change it back. I appreciate this feedback very much!
https://itch.io/jam/scream-jam-2024/rate/3052001
Thanks for taking the time!
I played the game again! Unfortunately, I encountered the same bug :/ But no worries, I’ll still start with the positives.
Positives:
Negatives:
Conclusion: This is an incredible game with an intriguing story. I liked that the player is given minimal information, which makes you wonder, “Why are we here?” I wasn’t entirely sure if the right combination allowed me to proceed or if the game advanced after a certain number of attempts, but maybe that doesn’t matter. I read other players' comments and agree with those who compared the game to The Talos Principle. It really has that sense of loneliness and mystery. You achieved an amazing result for a 10-day game jam, despite the bug slightly affecting my experience. Thank you for the game!
Thank you so much for playing and also for the helpful and detailed feedback!
We are so glad you enjoyed the visual style and the little treats like the corpse watching you and the eyes in the dark <.< Also the music - it was a lot of fun to make!
Exit 8 was definitely an inspiration for the looping! Its cool you mention it!
Although its a shame a bug got in the way of the ending, we are so grateful again for the playthrough and the kind words :)
Could you give me some feedback on my game? https://primechannel816.itch.io/you
Hi! Thanks for sending the link to your game! I'll start with the positives:
Now, for the downsides:
Overall: The game is short but spooky. The jump scares are pants-wettingly effective, and the plot twist works pretty well. It might’ve helped to focus more on the quest logic, especially finding the keys, and I would’ve loved a little cutscene at the end, showing the protagonist sneaking into the house and killing people. Thanks for sharing the game—it was awesome to play!
I would also appreciate it if you would play our game https://itch.io/jam/scream-jam-2024/rate/3038320
This is my game!! Its a job interview horror game!! Week of the Interview by CorgiStudios
Thanks for taking the time to review our game :) Hope you have fun!
https://itch.io/jam/scream-jam-2024/rate/3054228
Hi! I finally got around to playing your game and finished it. I'll start with the positives.
Positives:
Negatives:
Conclusion: Great game with an intriguing storyline. I’d be interested to learn more about the heroine’s story and what happened to her partner. Did he become the monster due to some kind of lunar curse? Anyway, I hope you continue the story so I can play it in the future. Thanks for the game!
Give my game a try please: https://itch.io/jam/scream-jam-2024/rate/3057286
Hi! Thank you for sending the link to your game! I'll start with the positives:
Positives:
Negatives:
Conclusion: A strange game—I can’t say I enjoyed it. The overcomplicated controls gave me hope it would be interesting, but only about 30% of the buttons seem to work. It feels like the game doesn’t have a clear sense of purpose. I don’t understand what we’re supposed to be doing or what the goal is. In any case, I hope my review isn’t too harsh and that maybe in the next game jam, you’ll make a much better game! Thank you for the game.
Hi! Thanks for sharing the game!
Positives:
Negatives:
Conclusion: The game is engaging, with a grounded story that feels unique. It almost seems like a real-life experience that inspired the developer to share it. I hope I’m wrong about that! Thanks for the game!
I would also appreciate it if you would play our game https://itch.io/jam/scream-jam-2024/rate/3038320
Here's our game: https://itch.io/jam/scream-jam-2024/rate/3058445 we're thinking about extending it and adding a few more features/fixes, so your feedback + rating would be super appreciated and useful! I'll play your game later today :)
Hi! Thank you for sending the link to your game!
Positives:
Negatives:
Conclusion: Out of all the games I’ve reviewed, this is the only one with no negatives, at least for me. Every aspect is well-crafted, and I have nothing to criticize. It might be nice to add some music to the game—for instance, a gramophone playing a melody that could also feature in the main menu. Overall, for a short timeframe, this is an exemplary game, and everyone should play it to see what’s possible within a short jam. Thank you for sharing your game.
I also hope that you will play our game! https://itch.io/jam/scream-jam-2024/rate/3038320
Hey there Skibidi!
Please play and rate this one! Give the description and lore a read before or after to enjoy the experience even more!
https://sdoku.itch.io/skibidi-man
Yours lovingly,
Skibidi Man
I won’t be voting for your game because I’m not too fond of the fact that you submit it to every game jam. I also found it rather strange that you are listed as the developer of two games in the same jam. If that’s really the case, maybe it would’ve been better for everyone to focus on just one game?
Thank you for sharing your game!
Positives:
Negatives:
Conclusion: The game feels small and unpolished and clearly needs more work. Please don’t take my words personally—I always aim to give honest feedback, and there will always be others to offer praise. I hope you gain more experience by the next game jam and make even better games! Thanks again for sharing your game!
You can also play our game https://itch.io/jam/scream-jam-2024/rate/3038320
thank you for your feedback.
answers.
1. i will fix the menu once the game jam is over adding buttons such as (start settings, difficulty, and help)
2.im sorry you weren't able to see the jump scare do you mind giving me more info on what was happening in the game and what you were doing when the jump scare happened?
3.that is the fourth obsticale when that comes up as it says in the corner of the screen you just have to type "cmd clr" (standing for command clear) and your cameras will come back up.
Thank you for explaining; I hadn’t noticed the command line. I replayed the game, and yes, things became much clearer, and I finally saw that ninja jump scare XD.
About the error: I wasn’t doing anything special. I heard the sound of breaking glass, and then I think a monster attacked me, after which the game crashed with an error.
https://itch.io/jam/scream-jam-2024/rate/3057312
Would love any feedback we can get!
Hi! Thanks for sharing the link!
Pros:
Cons:
Summary:
A fun game with an interesting dimension-switching mechanic. The graphics, done in Synty assets, were pleasing. It’s a shame there’s no backstory for the main character or why they’re there, but those are minor things. Thanks again for sharing your game!
You can also play our game https://itch.io/jam/scream-jam-2024/rate/3038320
Here is mine if you are interested, please read the description:
https://itch.io/jam/scream-jam-2024/rate/3058994
Hi! Thanks for sharing the link to your game!
Positives:
Negatives:
Conclusion: I really enjoyed the game; the atmosphere is mesmerizing. I didn’t fully understand the storyline, but the strange events happening to the character were enough for me. The music, sound, and visual style were all top-notch. I also enjoyed exploring the location, even though the combat could use some refinement. I hope you finish the game, and I’d love to play the full version! Thanks for the game!
You can also play our game https://itch.io/jam/scream-jam-2024/rate/3038320
Hey, thanks for playing, the combat really needs to be refined, I ended up doing everything in a rush, the game map was the one that took the longest to make. So to make time to release it at the jam, I had to cut the story, which would have had two endings, and I had to reuse some of the soundtracks for the ghost combat from other projects. The artwork for some parts of the game is still missing, the menu artwork itself isn't even done yet. Anyway, I'll try to release it next month, thank you very much for your comment and for the recommendations of games for me to use as inspiration.
By the way, I downloaded your game, but it doesn't run very well on my pc, it's very laggy and it's almost impossible to play :(
I don't know if there are any settings to make it lighter, but even though I can't play it, I gave it a rating based on the tutorial video on the game's page.
Hi everyone once again! I’m closing feedback requests as I'm starting to feel fatigued from playing games. I’ll finish playing the remaining games listed in this post, but I’ll be ignoring any new ones. Thank you to everyone who reached out—I’ve played many interesting games and gained a lot of experience! Thanks again!
I want to share with you the games that I enjoyed the most out of all the others.
That’s about it. I know there are plenty of other great games in this game jam, like The Dollhouse and The Children of Clay. I enjoyed these games as well, but I wanted to spotlight the ones I felt might have been overlooked, and they deserve much more recognition! Thank you for reading this post, and I hope you’ll play and rate the games I mentioned!