A window resize option would have been nice to have, my screen was too small for the game window to show properly.
Loved the descriptions for the items and the atrocities that I ended up cooking.

I had as much fun playing the game as reading all the lovely comments here, and now I feel like I have nothing to add XD

Voiceover, even if double was fantastic! Well done for coming back after so many game jams! I remember playing "It's Still Me" like it was yesterday :D

I give up. I can't seem to find the perfect extra for my soap soup. This was fun! I encountered a couple of bugs though. The voice over doesn't seem to stop when moving to something else. There were times that I could hear three different things being said at the same time. And no, I can't turn voice over off, even though I'm perfectly capable of reading. Because, you know, I just love voice overs.

Another thing which I don't whether it was a bug or a feature, was that some ingredients weren't there at first and somehow suddenly appeared. Pizza crust and bacon are two that I remember. And I don't think the chicken was always there either.

Anyway, enough with negativity. I liked that there were a lot of text written for different combinations and different ingredients. That's another thing I enjoy.

All in all, I'd consider this an excellent concept. I'm very likely to buy a fully fledged game built around this idea. Great job.

This is a good game! I loved the commitment to accessibility through all the voiceovers, and creating crazy combinations was a lot of fun

If you click "Make a Substitution" before adding any ingredients it just shows a grey box, which I initially thought was a bug, so maybe adding some guidance here that the player should go to the fridge first would be helpful.

Neat idea. Great writing and voice over, and music. Seems like quite a big challenge to take on for a jam game (hey, a pun!) given how many different combinations you had to think of!

I found it tricky to understand if I’d done well or not… It seems I could pretty much always progress to the next recipe, no matter what I put on. I did enjoy the comments when I put something weird on. I got to Mac and Cheese and couldn’t get any further. Is that the end?

I really liked this game. It's very impressive, that you managed to have a voice over for basically everything.  The writing was funny and I really wanted to find all possible substitutions. Unfortunately, the game seems to crash whenever you find the one ingredient non-food substitute. That's doubly unfortunate, because finding the whacky way of making the food work was definitely the most fun part of the game for me. It also sometimes feels arbitrary which substitutes work and which don't and the game gives little guidance towards the right options. Of course, working out every combination a player could think of would be waaay out of scope. The amount of valid substitutes and extras is big enough as it is.

The setting options are really nice, but the out-of-the-box settings  seem weirdly balanced. But that's just a nitpick.

All in all, I really enjoyed it though, and the game really had my kind of humor.

I liked it. I couldn't find good substitutions in any recipe (so I'd argue there's some difficulty that can be fixed with hints maybe), but overall, this was a really interesting idea. I think it could have been polished a little more. Oh, I did think the default music level was too strong for the default voice level. I really liked how you did the voice over effect, so I'd suggest toning down the music level even more by default. (I know I can change it, but I could barely hear the voice on normal level).