Thanks again!
- Ok, it should be Adventure mode;
- Artifacts can be found only by opening treasure chests, and are announced with a huge box UI entitled "Artifact Found!"; any other thing you can find in the ground of a dungeon are consumables (potion, bomb, time rune, key) and currency (4 colour type coins, gems and dark matter);
- Yeah, i noticed that people is not paying much attention to the compass in worldmap so i'm currently boosting a lot the UI in order to make sure a player will be bound to notice it.
- I see, i'll consider a button to enlarge/shrink the dungeon minimap, thanks!
- Ok, coins can be used to shop consumables in cities, or they can be used in the inventory to upgrade your weapons;
- I think i got what it happened here... there's a flaw in the resolution of WegGL version that won't show up the boundaries of a battle screen, that means that you won't see the UI that shows you/the enemies can escape from battle when crossing that red line:
In the downloaded version it can be seen, maybe even the current web version, at full screen should be able to show that line on the screen;
- Ok, the spinning needle in worldmap only refers to worldmap position, there's no connection to your position, while inside a dungeon;
- So, about the "black artifacts", in the screenshot i noticed only those 2 things:
this is the "enter city" icon, and clicking it will open the city UI;
those instead are dark stains, they appear and enlarge when you pass through a tile in worldmap, if you pass through the same tile more that x times, after y time has passed... something will happen;If you're talking about anything else, related to that screenshot, then i have no idea what you're talking about @_@;
- Yes they give exp and coins and potentially they can make you level up, though it's quite unprobable... for example in a lv1 dungeon, enemies give 2 XP; the dungeon boss gives 20 XP; the treasure chest gives 200 (or 250, i don't remember) XP, this is what i mean when i say it heavily depends on treasures gaining XP. To level up from lv 1 to level 2 you need 300 XP. In Adventure mode the XP gain is 3x and artifact chests is 6x;
I'm definitely glad if you provide further QA in future! While you say it's free, you still call it offer... why? I mean, i don't think it exists any developer who would reject a free offer of testing, especially when it's quite detailed, unless i'm missing any implication.
The way you write your feedback seems professional and seems to follow a sort of template... could it be you're practicing to become an actual professional QA tester?
Hi William! Wow, thanks for the long feedback!!
First of all i'd like to ask you 3 questions:
1 - Did you choose Adventure Mode or Campaign Mode?
2 - How many artifacts did you found?
3 - Did you reach the end of the demo?
To answer your feedback:
- The Compass Shield is both for Finding Artifacts in worldmap, Special move in dungeon (damage/destroy, exploration, speed and invincibility) and a skillset in battle, so it's a multiuse powerful tool. You mentioned later that the multifunction might confuse the player, would you suggest some extra info for the player? The functions of the Compass Shield are mentioned in its tutorial;
- Actually in dungeon in the box in the bottomright there's a UI dedicated to show the minimap of the current dungeon floor... since in The Binding of Isaac there was no explicit text that would say the UI is a minimap, i thought that maybe it was enough to get the player aware of its existence, but you're not the first one not noticing that, probably i'm gonna boost that UI (and many others), i wonder if making pulsate the white color of the current room could be enough...
- Do you think the current currency UI is hard to notice? Not sure i understood the one about finding the right shield, the wall destroy scene triggers by moving forward it, after finding the Compass Shield;
- When you mentioned purple boxes and pink squares, did you refer to the same thing? Those blocks are the so called Obstacles in dungeon, you and enemies cannot pass through them but you can destroy them (aside few exceptions) by hitting them with a bomb or the Shield Bash skill. Doing that will destroy them and there's a chance they drop a random loot;
- By flower tiles you mean this one?
This one is a trap (a sort of mud pool), which slows you down when you step on it. I wonder if there could be a way to make it perceive more like mud...
- Red balls enemies should be the Potion-type enemy, they are very fast enemies which will always try to run away from you, on the other hand if you manage to defeat them in battle, you'll get an extra prize. Potion minions are too fast but are optional, the boss versions can actually be defeated, but it requires a bit of strategy. Technically if you cannot reach them, you can still escape from the left side of the screen so the battle will end sooner, but i'm planning to enforce their early escape from battle in case they become too distant from the player, without waiting they reach the right edge of the battle screen, by the way. By locked in a loop, you meant that you were stuck in dungeon in a spot in which it was impossible to avoid the potion? Technically if you have the Compass Shield, there's should always be a wayout;
- Could you elaborate further on the West -> East feedback, please? Not sure if i undertood what you meant... maybe that when you exit a dungeon, the needle direction is inconsistent, compared to the actual position of the next artifact?
- I didn't get what you meant by Black Artifacts... maybe the stains of darkness that appear where you walk? Or the eyes and mouths that spawn during the night?
- About the experience, at the current state the weight of exp gain is strongly pushed toward Treasures and Quests, while the exp gain by monster defeat is quite low and might not be perceived... should i distribute the exp budget more on favor of monster defeat? (the core source should still be Treasure and Quests) Or maybe it's enough increase the exp gain feedback, like some particle effect or a UI display, next to the exp bar?
- The Demo barely scratches the surface of the game, actually the game already features dungeons with several floors, in the next areas, in certain biomes (if you find the artifact that allows you to walk through forest tiles, forest dungeons have 2 floors). Not reccomended, but also dark dungeons have 2+ floors;
- There are the silver keys, not sure what you mean about the red one, though;
- Thanks again for the feedback, without any doubt i'll collect those feedbacks to enhance further the game! I'd definitely love to hear more feedbacks from you in feature, especially after i release new updates;
- There's only one way to know more answers about The Hand: playing further! (I'm quite confident you'll inevitably "meet" it, according to luck, skill, game mode and duration of the run)
Hi! Here i am, i can finally proceed with the making of The Rogue of Nexus. (part 2)
Very well, so i shown the mock up to my boss and he liked it, reccomendations aside.
Time to start with developement, right? Nope.
That could be a thing on solo developement and/or making a game as hobby, but i'm not alone, and allies aside, there's a budget to validate and approve, which is provided from above, and the guys above need to know how that money will be spent (more precisely which tasks will be performed, which assets will be created and how much they cost) and more importantly how time will be spent, in order to meet deadline.
This "wonderful" phase is called Pre-Production and, while success cannot be determined just by that, a poormade pre-production will grant a hullova of problems and probably the failure of a paid project as well.
One of the previous projects i joined, a year after it's developement start, i think it suffered heavily this issue: the producer changed 1-2 times and the GDD changed a couple of times as well, i had to rewrite it on my own... the biggest issue is that the production and developement never communicated clearly on the goal to achieve and milestones to follow, so i basically tried to make a huge GDD, when problems started to come, the game had to be launched quite suddenly and in the mean time it was impossible to meet the expectation of the GDD, since the scope of the game shrank drammatically. The product has been launched with severe flaws and some of them still lurk in the shadow...
Please plan pre-production if you can.
The name of the phase strongly implies that a producer should deal with that, i'm a producer? No.
The producer of the italian team Studio Evil once taught at us (it was a game design course) that a Game Designer should never be a Producer at the same time (and vice-versa), i can agree with that: basically a Game Designer would want to build an incredible universe in its game; the Producer is there to remember that the team has X budget and Y time, so probably that universe is bound to become a bit/much less incredible that Game Designer's best scenario. Basically they are like the Hero and the Villain... there's a clear conflict of interest here.
However i personally think that it's quite important for a game designer to learn that stuff, even in case it will never happen to do that... both for gaining a bit of common sense and also because a game designer needs to know the gist of all developement processes, even to interact better with the whole team.
Well actually it's not like i was going to go through the whole process here, some week later a producer would join the project and provide a lot of help, in any case if you're the author of the game, then only you is aware of what the game is supposed to contain and (hopefully) the implications, namely the concrete effort and the list of assets to assemble the whole thing, so you must be aware of what they will cost, in all means.
My boss shared some info in how to do that, so i practiced a bit.
Here's a quick list of stuff i use in the meantime:
- Google Drive for store the documents of the project, which are destined to become a lot;
- Google docs (mostly for the equivalent of Word and Excel);
- Notepad, can't be more simple than that for writing quickly some text, planning stuff and listing ideas;
- Paint, i don't think a game designer necessarily needs more than that for a mockup or slap references quickly, keep it simple at this stage of developement.
What i need here is the Excel-like sheet, you need to line up assets, number costs and time cost, and other stuff.
This is what i came up with as first attempt:
Well, i mashed up the 3 sheets of the doc to fit in one image, but basically it features:
1 - The costs of the core, namely the essential part of the game, that cannot be cut in subsets of the whole part, like core gimmicks, the main character, darkness etc;
2 - The costs for each area, stuff that increase of number as the number of areas of the game increase, like x objects or y enemies... they are supposed to amount to the same value, so if making an area costs Z, then making 10 areas should cost Z * 10;
3 - Overall costs recap, this sums up the whole cost and can esily show how the costs scales according to the cuts or extra contents to the previous sheets, make sure to let the sheets use the formula to sum, multiply and all that jazz, and more importatly to make them talk with the third sheet.
This document must be quite readable, each line is supposed to describe what are you talking about, so the subject (an asset, a gimmick, a whole block of tasks), a brief description, the quantity, the cost and the total.
You show this to the publisher, maybe you'll do it much more professional than this, but that's the juice, and at the end of the story what they actually care is the last sheet, which in other words tells if costs vs budget are ok.
If you checked the content of the sheet, you might have realized that here we're talking just of costs in terms of time, after all it's useless to detail on money if you can't even balance the costs in term of time.
My budget in terms of time, technically speaking ammounted to 6 months, raw math says that even assuming you work like a machine, that equals to 180 days.
If you remember what i said in the previous part of this flashback, then you know i talked about making 10 areas... according to that sheet that's plain impossible, the numbers talks clearly: Even if text and numbers don't match, technically that was the cost of 4 areas and it did amount to more or less 515 days.
The core alone was too big already... it's time to make cuts to contents, lower the amount of areas and also receive a hand: (not The Hand!) i cannot do everything alone, starting from pixel art, but such truth was known already and i already talked about that with my boss: the developement team of The Rogue of Nexus is about to recruit members.
That was more or less the first week of pre-production, but obviously it doesn't end here... but we'll stop here for now. The next part will tell more about what happened then. Stay tuned!
Ok, i was supposed to post the following part about pre-production, but i'm too busy with the 1.1.2 update which is supposed to be released this friday, so in the meantime i'm gonna make a shorter post about the current WIP, (i'll post about pre-production the next week).
Aside the Adventure mode i mentioned elsewhere on Itch, probably the Discord and Reddit, i'm dealing with several UI/UX polishing and improvements, the one on the screen is a feature that allows to not getting stuck among darkness, at night.
So the feature is a sort of emergency time shift forward, the day/night time will immediately arrive to dawn, in this way night will fade, along whose eyes and jaws which lurk among darkness... but at the price of a life.
Well, without context it seems a bit weird, if not uncovenient as feature, let's say 50% yes and 50% no. I didn't provide extra details in other places i posted, but here in the devlog i have the chance to elaborate further:
1 - Why shifting from night to day? There are several rules about this world of darkness: it's not just about making disappear those creepy dark beings, mostly they revolve around The Hand. This being can destroy your path and it will turn into darkness. It is possible to attempt traveling along darkness, in worldmap but aside being very dangerous, you can do that only during day, in fact if night comes while you're in darkness then The Hand will catch you immediately. If it's already night you won't be able to interact with tiles of darkness;
2 - Why shifting instead of waiting? You can just wait, or doing something else meanwhile... or you can rest in a Safe Spot to also make day/night time shift forward of 6 hours, yet sometimes if darkness destruction surrounds you, you might be locked and isolated from the rest of the world, until dawn comes, and that's why your movement choices in worldmap are extremely important, during a run. Waiting several minutes (up to a max of 15) might not be exactly entertaining, so i added an option to skip that part;
3 - Why a penality? Without a penality, it would be a trick, an exploit and speedrunning tool that basically allows to skip night and that's not something i'd want to make happen, let alone skipping darkness: the path wouln't even be hindered in such case and the core gimmick would crumble;
4 - Life penality, too harsh? Not exactly, Abyss Upgrades allow to boost your starting run amount of lives, you start with more than one and, while losing the last life will make The Hand to suddenly attempt to grab you, losing a life this way won't make The Hand come out. You can even free yourself from the grab attempt if you're strong enough to handle the fight. Your lives can reach a negative value, in that case the following battles against The Hand will become harder to endure, so the Time Penality will shorten this process, if used several times;
5 - Flash Step penality, too harsh? Nope, Flash Step is an emergency button for escape almost from anything, darkness included, it's supposed to recharge at dawn, but not in this case, otherwise that would open to almost endless travelling along paths of darkness.
In the end, the Time Penality feature is only supposed to allow a fast transition in points of the run that would otherwise make the player get stuck temporally, not a way to escape from a bad scenario: if you got surrounded by darkness, you'll still have to venture through darkness when dawn will come.
If you just want to use the feature to skip time, then your lives will be the currency for that.
See us when the next update and devlog page will come!
