I had some free time this morning and I attempted to make the first page look like a 1950s menu, if you have a minute, I'd love to know if you think it "works" for the adventure or is a step in the wrong direction. If you're too busy, no worries! No need for detail specific feedback.
11 days ago (+1)
Thank you for the feedback! Are you referring to the title at the top with the checker background or the the other changes to make it more like a menu? Here is the version with the original header but the other changes in place for reference. 
11 days ago(+1)
I meant that the top looked too hard to read, this is great though! I know the header fonts aren't necessarily "on theme"for a menu but they wouldn't look out of place on a diner menu, plus the bloody font enforces up front that this is horror game and the contrast with the other elements adds a lot of comedy.