Someone was hoping to have similar system than this for non-web based games so I created another topic for that. If you want to read about the more on the context of this system check the original post trough the link. If you would like one for some other platform you can set something like that up yourself or you can send me a message and I will be happy to help.
RULES
Requirements for participations:
- You have submission that is playable with Windows operating system (includes also games playable on browser)
- You are able and willing to download Windows only submission to play and review them
- You have not yet played the game linked in the the current latest comment. (If you have played it already, please wait for someone else to link their game first so everyone will get new players!)
Do the following 3 steps to participate:
- Post link to your game as a comment to this topic.
- Play, rate and comment (in the rating page of the game not here!) the game linked in the previous comment.
- Wait for the next person to comment to this topic and then do step 2 for that game too.
You are free to repeat above steps as many times as you would like if you want more feedback.
HOW TO GIVE GOOD FEEDBACK?
- What were the best 1-3 parts of the game?
- Why was it cool or why did you enjoyed it?
- They don't really have to be "the best" parts but something that you think is worth mentioning. It can be something general (like the art style) or something very specific ("that one tree on the background of the last section in level 2").
- Even if you don't like a game in general there should always be some nice part of the game or something that you considered better than the other parts.
- Positive feedback is meant to reward the game creator for their work, tell them what they did well, and motivate continue creating games!
- What would be the top 1-3 things to improve?
- Remember to be constructive! Don't say things like: "Your character controller is trash". Instead tell how they could improve/fix the thing you are commenting about: "I think the game would be more fun if the character could move faster." / "When I was learning programming character control this one tutorial helped me a lot: [link]" / "I noticed a bug that the character can sometimes jump second time. It happened to me usually when I was nearby a wall."
- Constructive criticism is meant for the game creator to learn&improve or let them no about an issue they did not know they game had.
