Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines

What is the point in using itch if my games don't get shared on the platform?

A topic by soaringmoon created Mar 25, 2025 Views: 383 Replies: 13
Viewing posts 1 to 3
(1 edit)

That is my question. I just learned that 4 of my 6 games have never been indexed.

I read the quarantine topic, which is vague and only explains basic alchemy of how to not get delisted. Most of which I feel I have done. 

There is a list of quality guidelines, which are not explained to any user at any part of the page creation process. Publishing a page before it's deemed "finished" by an arbitrary algorithm will prevent your games from being shown on itch.

Would I post youtube videos if they didn't appear on the suggested feed?

Would I use bluesky if my posts didn't appear in those hashtags?

I makes no sense at all to delist games on this platform, for really any reason that isn't a TOS violation or crime. I want this to make sense but it doesn't.

Moderator(+1)

You mean like the game you published less than a week ago? Yes, as explained in the post you said you've read, it can take that long. And that's exactly it: unfortunately, a lot of people try to upload all kinds of bad stuff to itch.io, so newly published pages often have to be checked first.

(2 edits)

> You mean like the game you published less than a week ago?

Are you trying to be intentionally disingenuous?

The page you are referencing was published in October.

https://soaringmoon.itch.io/cosmic-construct/devlog
Interesting that I have been writing devlogs for 14 weeks for a game 1 week old.

What about the other 3 pages you intentionally ignored my concerns for?
Some of which were posted around a year ago?

These are not "newly published".

Moderator (2 edits) (+1)

You're right, my bad. I was looking at the wrong field. That said, changes you've made recently can also cause your games to be placed back in the review queue. And which three pages, out of the six games you have published? I looked at the last one, and you're right, but see above.

To answer the question in your post title, site search is intended for players to easily locate games they already know about. It's not a marketing tool. Our admins are asking creators to do their own promotion through other channels rather than rely on itch.io for that.

Both things I've just explained are mentioned in the unofficial FAQ you said you've read.

(1 edit)

https://soaringmoon.itch.io/cosmic-connect - Updated Jul 06, 2024

https://soaringmoon.itch.io/facetfinal - Updated Dec 11, 2024

https://soaringmoon.itch.io/nandroid-generator - Updated Oct 30, 2024

https://soaringmoon.itch.io/cosmic-construct - Updated 5 days ago

The last of which has a steam page. I uploaded a playtesting build for a gamejam which was removed after that playtest period.

> is intended for players to easily locate games they already know about

Here is the quote that tipped me off to this.

> cant find it when searching so it should be
>https://itch.io/search?q=Cosmic+Construct

Firstly, if it isn't a marketing tool, then nobody should trust it to have sales for their game or generate itch revenue. Probably not a good thing to tell anyone in the community here. Why would I not use itch's game directory if it doesn't sell video games?

Secondly. People only have been finding my games through a direct link to my creator page.
Searches for my titles don't include the 4 above games.

Moderator

It looks like the first three were overlooked, or got stuck in the queue. I'm not sure how the process works, but I can speed things up for you. The last one might have been queued up again due to the recent changes.

(1 edit)

>speed things up for you

Okay thank you. But what about everyone else on the platform?

>The last one might have been queued up again due to the recent changes.

It... has... never... been... indexed.

Moderator

I have no way of knowing if it was indexed before or not. And I can't speak for everyone on itch.io either.

(+2)

Please, do not disrespect the moderator.
I understand your anger, I am also having issues with the platform that make me feel very bad and frustrated, but the moderator can only relay our complaints to the administrators to try to help us. Let's be thankful that at least he responds quickly. What will we do if more people start bothering him and he ends up stopping responding to our questions and trying to help us? Even if his answers don’t always reassure us, let’s thank him for helping.

I'll respect the moderator when they respect me.

If they have having staffing or response queue issues, that's not really my problem.

  • You mean like the game you published less than a week ago?
  • Yes, as explained in the post you said you've read
  • Both things I've just explained are mentioned in the unofficial FAQ you said you've read.

When they open with a condescending know it all tone making assumptions without reading they don't deserve my respect.

Just because the forum gets inundated by a bunch of people with the same wearily often problem that it becomes irritating. Does not mean you take it out on the people bringing up that issue.

For the information of everyone else here.

3 of the aforementioned games are now showing up in search results. (Yes, that quickly after complaining about it right?)

I was motivated to check after a sudden unexplainable spike in traffic.

Cosmic Construct is still not listed (which makes sense as it doesn't have a download available currently).

How envious. In two months, I'll probably still be here, watching others get their problems fixed and just feeling envious.

Posted here to represent people like you.
Crazy how this keeps happening. Clearly their "algo" is broken in some strange way.

I easily saw over 500 hundred malware pages last year in a few months. Most of those on hacked accounts.

What you see happening is Itch doing something about this. That this means delisting and quarantining with a shotgun instead of a scalpel is frustrating for developers. But even a quarantined game can be downloaded. If you have zero promotion happening and only accidental traffic, that is extra frustrating.

But I rather have some developers be delisted for a few weeks and see their complain threads, than see hundreds of hacked accounts spreading more malware.

This topic has been auto-archived and can no longer be posted in because there haven't been any posts in a while.