The Good, The Bad, The Ugly.
The Good; There are an absolutely insane amount of icons here for the price. A lot of them are incredibly well done, and look amazing. Specific examples would be the elemental equipment and other element tinged items. A lot of the basic RTP styled icons are great too.
The Bad, While there are a tonne of Icons there are some missing Icons as well, namely the normal variant of most of the equipment. You can see the normal variants in the pack, but they are all in a single section with various mini icons on them in the 'buffs & debuts' section. Those would have been good to have alongside the rest for a complete feeling.
The Ugly, There is an over reliance on Hue Shifted icons. It works great with the liquids in potion bottles, and different kinds of Gems/Crystals. It looks incredibly garish with the equipment, making a good portion of the icons kind of unusable as they don't really fit in alongside a lot of the other icons for gear.
My favorites are definitely the elemental items. It shows that a lot of love wen't into those icons, the over abundance of hue shifted equipment unfortunately brings things down, as they feel like little more than a forced way to 'pad out' the volume of the icons to reach that high number. This wouldn't be too bad if only accents, or parts of them were hue shifted, but in most cases the majority of the item is, while the accent stays the same color. This can leave some of them in a state that it's difficult to distinguish what the item actually is on its own without the less vibrant color next to it.
I would have liked to see individual files for each icon as well, but that's a personal preference for ease of use in pick and packing an icon sheet from a large collection of icons.
In the end, the icons that are good, are really good. The icons that are bad, are really bad. Overall I like the pack, but it doesn't wow me.
itch.io is an open marketplace for independent game creators. It's completely free to upload your content. Read more about what we're trying to accomplish and the features we provide.