Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines

Is text to speech programs generative AI?

A topic by banana mugger created 4 days ago Views: 180 Replies: 5
Viewing posts 1 to 4

I am developing a ghost hunting game and I am currently thinking about how to add voice lines to the spirit box. In real life "ghosts" are meant to grab words from radio waves to speak giving it a robatic-ish sounding voice. I am thinking about using a text to speech program  to replicate robatic-ish tone.  I have no moral issues using text to speech since there programs that get the consent of VAs to replicate their voices and the technology for it are decades old.  But I do not want to demean  my work by forcing myself to add generative AI tag as my project is mostly my effort and assets that are not mine are legally acquired by human artists. I prefer not adding the tag but I want to be honest to players and I am getting mixed signals on the internet if text to speech is generative AI or not. I am just wondering what the general opinion Itch.io community on the use of text to speech programs. If I am sensing that this community is leaning of yes then I will record my  voice for the spirit box lines (not too much of an issue). 

(+1)

No. Text-to-speech isn't generative AI "per se." However, there are several text-to-speech programs that DO use generative AI to create the voices.

What you need to look for is a program that doesn't use generative AI. You could try an older text-to-speech program to be safe, but that's just a suggestion.

I am planning to stick to one of the older versions of Microsoft Voice but also manually tweaking it in audio editing software.  I guess I am in the clear for generative AI use if I stick to that.  Thanks for the suggestion. 

(+1)

Do you need to use a "prompt" to generate the audio? Then it is gen ai. Telling a thing to read out loud a line is not a prompt. Telling it to read it in a spooky voice is. And if you can do such voice styles in the first place by telling the system, that also is a huge hint that it might be gen ai. Maybe read the docs of whatever system you use to find out what kind of voice generation it uses.

But what you describe will not be what you described. A ghost using radio waves and grabbing the audio in those waves to communicate would not sound like a retro robot. It would sound like Bumblebee in the Transformer movies.

I think you mean voices like from a radio station that is not quite tuned in and fades in and out and has static noise and such. Maybe combined with how Bumblebee would "talk". There might be filters in audio manipulation apps to achieve such effects.

(+1)

I was planing on getting text to voice to read aloud what I wrote then tweaking it in an audio editing software. I was struggling to describe the spirit box radio talk when I use the word robot-ish I don't mean retro robot but something that don't sound  human. I guess Bumblebee is the best example. Thanks for your reply.

(+1)

Not all text2speech AI requires a promp. And not all Text2Speech is AI. (As hechelion said above)

Loquendo and  Balabolka are not AI generated for example.

 In the other hand Bark and CoquiTTS are AI.

In the legal issue, i think there is a CC0 voice bank you can use. In XTTS or (CoquiXTTS) you only need a 10s voice sample of the voice you want the characters to have. It can be even your own voice distorted. Or perhaps since you want 'ghostly voices' you can use your own voice distorted in Audacity with a noise background and a bit of echo effect? IDK what's more easy for yah.

'

But I do not want to demean  my work by forcing myself to add generative AI tag as my project is mostly my effort and assets that are not mine are legally acquired by human artists. I prefer not adding the tag but I want to be honest to players and I am getting mixed signals on the internet if text to speech is generative AI or not.

' <- Share the feeling dude, i am also a pro-AI user. I personally i don't have issues enyoing something with AI generated content. The worl (or internet) is mostly polarized in the issue right now because is a new thing in general. Do what you think is correct and suits you well.

Good luck with your project.

:-)