Recent community posts
Enjoying this but I feel like the weed pulling (at least in the early game) demands a lot of attention for an idle game. I could never quite leave it alone / it was some unexpected low key anxiety
well, I'm a hardhatbeetle in this version, which is kinda cool tbh
I probably don't need to point out what's broken, so instead I'll stick to the big picture:
- you made a lot of great progress as a whole, doing group debug is a really great way to learn development... honestly I'm a little happy you refactored because now you're all collaborating hardcore, despite how stressful it is for you
- but uh obviously in the future, beware of doing a project-wide refactor as you approach a project deadline... most game studios would never refactor everything as late as you've done... or, maybe there could've been a different way to approach the refactor? or maybe the refactor could've been more modular and slower? stuff to think about re: your development approach for the next 2-3 years of projects here at game center
I got to 999m!!! really great progress, it feels like it's coming together
- add sound!! very important for the game feel here!!
- make sure death camera doesn't keep scrolling horizontally, and don't let death camera drop too low (or else it destroys the illusion of your buildings)
- imo you should be more generous with the jump timing, there's lots of instances where I jumped off too late but I felt like I should've been able to jump anyway? in platformer design we call this "coyote time" where we let the player jump for a little while even after they leave the ledge... let me know if you need help brainstorming how to code this
great progress! love how big the map is, and a lot of the core features are working, and the variety of enemy behavior is impressive
I can't figure out how to get money though? everything I killed dropped either nothing (99% of the time) or a heart (1% of the time)... is that how it was in the original version?
the knockback from enemies feels kinda intense and laggy, if possible you might want to tint the player sprite (or use a coroutine to make the player sprite flash red) to explain the stun frames / knockback cooldown before we can move again... also maybe tune down the knock back a little? idk
in general the enemy collision feels too big and ungenerous to the player, like if I just barely graze the enemy I get knocked back 20 feet? if possible, make the enemy collision smaller so that we have to get closer to an enemy before we get knocked back
love the catfish crash zoom mechanic, kinda wish the fish would've reacted to being looked at? great surreal feel to it tho... and wikipedia says this type of catfish can breathe air and walk a little?? intense!! didn't know this game was so IRL
controls seem a bit laggy sometimes, and sometime link's facing direction doesn't match the movement direction / input?
controls are actually reversed in game,,, for me, X is sword, Z is shield?
cool to see combat working! sword attack doesn't feel super reliable though, sometimes it feels like I should be hitting enemies (and visually the sword touches the enemy) but then the enemy takes no damage? this is mostly a problem with the little bouncey blob monsters... so make the damage raycasts more generous? you can make the raycast longer, or use something like circlecast (which is like a thick raycast)
add in some basic sound for various actions and player inputs will make the player controller feel more solid, so maybe it's time to add a bit of that in
implement pits / damage soon, it's hard to test the combat when we can move wherever and enemies don't hurt us
you might need to scope down in other areas to focus on the core combat more
good progress, and art is good!... no more sprite tasks! focus on the other aspects now lol
movement feels a little heavy and laggy... how are you doing input?
yeah the knockback is uhhh intense lol... some ways to improve physics stability:
- make sure you're using rigidbody velocity or force in the knockback, don't use transform.translate and don't edit position
- weaker knockback force?
- set player's rigidbody to continuous
- if all else fails, you can also raycast behind player to find the nearest wall, and then apply a weaker force based on the distance to the wall
the enemy's fireball shoot rate seems a little weird? is it like that in the original?
good progress though! make sure you leave a little time for juice and game feel... like you need some basic sounds (especially for combat!) and also change the font to be a pixel-looking font
- parallax offsets should always be slower vs. the further back you go into the background... i.e. it's weird that the back parallax is scrolling faster than the front parallax, tune the parallax more
- falling animation and rolling animation feel solid enough to me, but I think running animation needs another pass, leg movement is a little awkward, is there a misplaced frame?... also maybe adjust the framerate on the animations, could be a bit faster or more fluid?
- core gameplay is almost there, now push it more and make sure the juice and tuning and sound is there!
- it's ok to replace the credits with your own names in the final version, as long as you make clear this was a exercise for school and you're not actually trying to steal Canabalt lol
https://imgur.com/a/aX96e2F ... bug report: I got stuck on the edge of the building and now I can't fall down :( ... you might need a special collider / trigger on the sides of buildings, OR use PlatformEffector2D to disable side friction, you'll have to see what works best for your scene setup
(windows, standalone desktop build) took me a couple tries to really get the controls, but once I did, it felt mostly solid and I was able to navigate around between the rooms! good progress
- start thinking about the level design and tutorial now... you need to train players to hold down left-click to aim, etc. and I didn't even know about the right-click thing
- the input feel could be streamlined a little bit... it's a bit strange that clicking = pick up object, but then holding down = throw object? it doesn't map neatly onto a hand metaphor exactly... or show a UI for charging up our throw? also maybe show a reticule for where our mouse is pointing, or always point the character toward the mouse cursor? etc.
- the preview arrow, when we're holding left-click, needs to be a bit more obvious (and maybe inverted, to preview our future trajectory instead of our throw trajectory)
- the clickable area on each object needs to be x3 bigger, right now it feels very stingy and ungenerous... make picking up objects feel juicy and nice (hover state, sound, particles, etc) to encourage players to use them!
- in one of the red dot rooms, I entered a weird soft-fail state where I was very slow and stuck in a corner with no objects near me!... do you have a plan for catching this soft fail state? make the walls bouncey? make all nearby objects automatically gravitate toward the player? (it seemed like maybe you were doing that? if so, the gravity felt a bit weak) etc.
- I mean, there's a scenario where you make this into a hardcore hard-sci-fi simulation where it's brutal and stuff... but the cute character and art style make me expect a smoother generous experience that doesn't punish me too hard, etc.
webgl on chrome
- the player vehicle physics are pretty solid, I was able to drive around pretty easily
- but I had a lot of trouble trying to pick up the capsules... I think the capsules might be too big, or the claw is too small? I kept hitting the capsule around, until the physics spring got broken and it blasted the capsule away and it fell through the gap
- do more level design, think about what the easiest capsule placement would be... I think picking up a capsule on the ground seems a bit hard for a first challenge, is there an easier situation you could design?
webgl on chrome
kinda brutal, I just kept dying on the first spike pit, was never able to really feel like I'm skating... probably need to tune the player physics to be more generous? maybe A/D can add slight impulse forces left and right? idk
could never really get SPACE working, or if it was working, it didn't feel like I was climbing the rope
also try designing an easy skateboard momentum level, what if level 2 was just a nice half pipe / ramp that lets us do a big jump? instead it's a very short drop with a wide spike pit, which is pretty hard
and even in your test level prototypes, make sure you clearly differentiate between platforms we can click on vs platforms we cannot click on... give them different colors
Windows, Client+Server (singleplayer?) mode
I was able to pick up a stick and throw it a very short distance? but if I didn't know that was an interaction already, I'm not sure I would've done it, it didn't look very important or clickable
main thing here seems to be playing with the dog... but it's very hard to know the dog's state, or what the dog might be thinking? in real-life we look at the dog's animations, face, behavior, etc. to guess... in this game, you might need to do different thought bubbles or emoji, or draw a line between the dog's position and dog's desire, etc. try to visualize the dog's mind so the player can understand the simulation better?
- in first screen, the clickable tutorial book should be 4 times bigger, make it very obvious
- the first puzzle should be easier? we don't even understand the goal of the game yet, and we need to rotate the chair? this should be level 3
imo you need a lot more UI feedback...
- preview to player when they are dragging object into an invalid position? it is annoying when the game snaps the object back into inventory with no warning
- show to player when the object is in correct place and giving progress toward next level... see zipzap
good progress though, the game concept is pretty clear and I was able to complete it