Just finished the game on Curated. It was neat to try to figure everything out, but I definitely had to guess at times. I think I had gotten everything correct, but the intuition saying I’ve “solved the important parts” for Dr. Darr made it frustratingly ambiguous.
I also have more thoughts and questions (SPOILERS WITHIN)
-
For Dr. Fleming, it’s unclear what the correct conclusion is supposed to be (or if there are multiple valid answers). You could make the case that her death was murder or accident, that the one most responsible is Dr. Wegener or Dr. Faraday, or that it happened in the Lab or the Empty Room.
-
I managed to figure out that Professor Cosmo was a dog eventually, but it’s not clear to me how you can know she was Dr. Feyman’s dog specifically? It helps explain how things happened, but it still feels like an unsubstantiated leap of logic.
-
I’m confused about the burnt bag with the bloody glove. Dr. Darr saved it from the fire in the Parlor, but then he went on to strangle Dr. Feyman and go to the Lab and attack Dr. Fleming, wrap himself up in gauze after getting stabbed, and run outside, with the bag somehow winding up in his hands at the end. How can that be? Did he have it in his pocket the whole time (but then why was it out of his pocket when he died? Did he leave it in the Parlor and only go back for it just before going outside?
-
Why was there a cast of a pocket watch in the freezer? I’m just now realizing that it must have been for making “The Unfailing Killer” out of ice. You mean it was just a pocket watch? I assumed it was some sort of standing clock. How could something that small be displayed with a clear enough view to be convinced that it was a diamond clock without giving away that it’s just a hunk of ice?
-
I don’t quite understand the logistics around the pill swap. I feel there must be something I misinterpreted. Dr. Faraday had tried stealing the whole bottle of Amazaphine, right? Otherwise it wouldn’t have been out of place. And only once everyone was gathered together did they plan to search everyone’s person for “The Unfailing Killer.” I know it says that Dr. Fleming was “easily distractable,” but how exactly, while everyone was in the same room, did Dr. Faraday manage to take out some Amazaphine pills from the bottle in her purse, get the painkiller bottle from Dr. Fleming’s purse, put the pills inside that bottle, put it back in her purse, and then crucially, have the Amazaphine bottle wind up back in the Lab, all before she got herself searched, and without anyone noticing?
-
Something I really don’t get is - Dr. Darr set up the whole party just so he could search Dr. Fleming’s purse and take back the necklace, but the whole plan hinges on her choosing to keep a valuable stolen necklace in her purse - and she does, for some unfathomable reason! Why would she bring it with her rather than keep it in a safe place in her home? I also find it hard to understand how he’d be able to pocket the necklace during the search, with everyone’s eyes no doubt on him the whole time. Dr. Fleming didn’t even seem to ever notice it was gone?
-
That brings me to the other thing I really don’t get - the necklace came from the attempted second kidnapping victim, where both the ownership of the necklace and the fear of it getting discovered indicate that this victim was cared for and had loved ones. But wasn’t the first victim chosen specifically because they wouldn’t be missed? Why would they break away from that for the second victim? The second victim getting killed because they fought back also indicates that they were older and stronger than the first victim, who was taken as a very young child. There was no indication that they needed a particular kind of person, so I don’t see any reason why for the second victim they wouldn’t have gone for someone similar to the first.


