I totally loved the atmosphere of the game, you got to expand it after the jam because I want a full version of it!
The graphics are awesome, 5/5 to me.
The soundtrack is awesome, I would have given a 5/5 fo audio if it wasn't for the sound fx that was a bit annoying sometimes like the one on the continue button that has a sharp and unpleasant attack and the dialogue track which is well recorded and acted but mixed too low compared to the music.
The story got me involved and I like how you used the theme of the jam not only for the mechanics but you gave it context in your story using religion and science as an example.
My first ending was neutral and as you said in the end dialogue maybe the theme of the jam spoiled the intentions of the narrator. If you had made a full game like this out of the context of the jam who knows what people would have chosen?
Congrats for this entry, this is refreshing comared to the other games in the jam, I hope you do well at the end of it!
You got a new follower!