I am saying this is the best version that is closest to the original, it just isn't complete. By "remake" you could have been including all of those games that are trying to be PT. If you know of a version better than this one I'd like to know about it.
https://www.polygon.com/2018/11/5/18056732/pt-remake-pc-free-download-itchio
https://www.gamespot.com/articles/silent-hills-pt-returns-as-a-free-fan-remake-o...
https://www.gamespot.com/articles/someones-remaking-silent-hills-pt-demo-on-pc/1...
https://arturlaczkowski.itch.io/playableteaser
https://www.gamesradar.com/8-amazing-remakes-pt/
https://www.denofgeek.com/us/games/pt/278465/pt-remake-vr-new-ending
https://radiusgordello.itch.io/unreal-pt
https://jedlondo.itch.io/punity
^ got shut down by Konami.
anyways, you get the picture.
That is far fewer than 40. Some of those links reference the same releases or aren't even downloadable. There is more likely a few available to download including the one here. Punity is still available but it isn't nearly as complete as this one. The problem is nobody has completely remade it yet. Some get close like this one and then abandon it or get it forcibly shutdown. In the end it's Konami's fault.
Exactly my point, exaggerating does not backup anything you are saying as truth. I've played both and Puntiy is not a complete version of PT, nor is it as complete as this game made by arturlaczkowski. Just because you think PT is "crappy" doesn't mean it is. The majority of us would like to play a complete version.