first off, this is the single best remake of P.T. , it's so close to 1:1 and none of the others are even close to the same level. I've been pretty obsessed with P.T. since it came out, so I thought I'd write down a list of things I noticed that were off from the original, if most of these are fixed I think this will be nearly 100% on par with the original. They are all fairly small things, but all together they add up to make it feel more like a remake and less like the original
- Talking bag only works if you get the jumpscare, if you go by the jumpscare and just get back to the starting room from the crash he wont talk, in the original he does.
- The headbob is too subtle, its much more exaggerated in the original which makes the player movement feel a lot weightier
- In the "gouge it out" hall, you should be able to see the shadow of lisa following you as you come up the hall
- The lisa jumpscare itself definitely needs a little work, honestly would not be mad if in that scenario only it just played the clip from the game. That jumpscare is too well crafted to properly recreate in my opinion
- The doors look a little funky. Either they are too shiny or the normal map is messed up a bit, maybe both
- The outside door in the main area doesn't make the locked sound when you walk into it
- The flashlight range is definitely too far, very evident when you see lisa on the balcony, in the original she will be just barely illuminated making it pretty terrifying, but here she is completely lit up making it a bit goofy looking. This is also caused by the lamp on the table having too big of a range
- In the bathroom, the door should only reopen if you zoom on the mirror, just glancing at it doesn't open it in the original which makes it more of a puzzle
- In the speedy red loop, different music should play depending on which direction the player is looking in
- The blood from the fridge should cover the player camera
Just to clarify, don't mean for any of this to be hating on this remake. It is genuinely amazing. It's just SO close to being perfect and I want to see it be the first remake to do it