The reason I wanted to contact this person in particular is because I’ve seen some of their other reviews and they appear well read and give great feedback.
I still think it’s a bad idea. If you want feedback, you can get it from people that are willing to give it. But that’s just my opinion, at the end of the day, it’s your decision how to approach this.
I did consider the Get Feedback page but in the rules it said “Itch projects only” and this isn’t a project so I figured my post would be struck with the mod hammer.
“Project” is a generic term, it applies to asset packs as well, and anything that has an Itch.io page. As a mod I’ve seen asset packs being posted there, and let them be. People like interacting with them, so it helps the community.