Play project
Dark Frost's itch.io pageResults
Criteria | Rank | Score* | Raw Score |
Mechanics | #33 | 3.250 | 3.250 |
Use of Theme | #33 | 3.417 | 3.417 |
Overall | #42 | 3.146 | 3.146 |
Setting (or Location) | #57 | 2.917 | 2.917 |
Story (or Starting Scenario) | #57 | 3.000 | 3.000 |
Ranked from 12 ratings. Score is adjusted from raw score by the median number of ratings per game in the jam.
Leave a comment
Log in with itch.io to leave a comment.
Comments
A very dark game, both literally and psychologically.
As others have commented, the difficulty is way to high even at "warm" temperatures. I just feel that there would be no build-up if you just make a bond and sacrifice someone straight away to succeed at a task. If it is easier at the beginning, and gets tougher as it gets colder, then there would be more opportunities for the bonds to develop. Just my opinion.
Oof. Kinda sorta Stockholm's Syndrome here, by the looks of it. While the mechanic is interesting and in the case of survival, fitting, it makes me feel icky.
I'm guessing each day the temperature drops? There's a missing sentence telling us the rate of temperature drop.Rereading it, I see that the Dark Frost catches up every 4 hours. But we have a few days to get to Lazarus? I guess that needs to be played out with the narrator. Like, three hour sleep shifts, with an hour or less of flat out running? Or sleep marching (via The Long Walk)? Also, "few" days is an unnecessary vagary that could easily have been "four" or "five" in order to increase character and player stress. In general "few" is three or, at most, four.And a trivial task is a 15? Even at 4d6 that's not trivial. It might have been better to say rolling a 3 or better on a die is a success, and you need 3 successes. That's at least a higher probability of success.
I apologize for sounding so harsh. I think the idea that someone who knows a hint of my dark secret can then sacrifice me in a daily event in order for an action to succeed (meaning we don't die, or whatever. But wow) is really off-putting. And then if they know my secret fully they can just abuse me at will. Ugh. The only reason I'm running with this other person is that I'm trying not to die and moving in groups is the best way to do that. Oh! This really grates my cheese!
I could swear this is the basis for some movies or reality shows. I'd have to play this with not-friends at a big party so I could avoid them until I left. This is a tough sell for me. It's good mechanics, even if the act of it is morally or ethically wrong. But then what other mechanic would there be? It is what it is, and it's decent. I really like the Dark Frost; would like to have seen that expanded. I don't love it overall, but I appreciate the work and thought behind this one.
I took from your preamble text the rule that the temperature should change every 4 hours and assumed that was the kind of standard action duration (so failing at making forward progress would result in the temperature dropping). Because the consequence is a more difficult subsequent check, this would encourage people to share secrets -- a good concept I'm not sure there's room to build a rulekit around in 200 words, with everything else you're doing. Nifty.
I like what you have going on for character cooperation and incentives to play around the Secrets, but I'm unsure how the GM is meant to utilize the temperature chart and the nature of threats in the environment. A little more about the scenario would have been nice. However, these are some really interesting ideas!
Thanks :)
Yeah, unfortunately I had to choose where to extend the details. The GM is free to play with the temperature however they like based on the challenge they want to create. A good rule could be "the longer you stay somewhere, the colder it gets".
In my mind, there would mostly be huge temperature changes between insides and outsides.