I have run this adventure twice now, with Shadowdark and it's been very enjoyable. The only thing I stumbled with were the Halls of Regret. The rooms are supposed to shift every time someone enters the area, but I feel like that's a neat idea that ends up being underwhelming because when are the PCs going to enter the area more than once? I suppose they go back that way when they leave, but that feels pretty much after-the-fact. The second time I ran the adventure I had the rooms shift every time they left one ... only letting them out once they'd gotten to experience each of the four rooms at least once. That worked a lot better.
Overall great! The Mad Goddess herself has become an important part of my campaign world. One of the PCs swore fealty to her so she made him a Warlock in her service, and now he's recruiting more townsfolk to come help rebuild the cathedral. Can't wait to see where this goes!
itch.io is an open marketplace for independent game creators. It's completely free to upload your content. Read more about what we're trying to accomplish and the features we provide.