I'm pretty picky about Ace Attorney fan game stuff, as I feel like it's very easy to capture the aesthetic without actually capturing the feel of the game.
For something that is potentially going to be a series of cases, the narrative is very generic seeming. It doesn't feel like the kind of story that could fit into a larger narrative (a la Trials and Tribulations). Also, I feel like since The Great Ace Attorney, my scrutiny for first cases has increased a lot, as I feel like both 1st cases from that spin-off series are great examples of what a case 1 can be. This just falls flat in comparison
Props, though, for the custom art assets / taking static game sprites and adding the talking animations to them.
itch.io is an open marketplace for independent game creators. It's completely free to upload your content. Read more about what we're trying to accomplish and the features we provide.