itch.io

Hi, 

In this game [0.5.9.198]-wasp-crossbones-(19)-(659083396).json, I used Ready for a Fight to change from Alter-Ego to Hero form. Wasp has two different hero forms. I was not given the change to choose which one I wanted to change to. 

Thanks in advance!

Hi,

That interaction was ruled against almost three years ago: 

Cosmo (Star-Lord, 20/Nebula, 20) was originally written to allow him to interact with any deck in the game. Many players have found him an invaluable companion for Doctor Strange and his invocation deck. However, we have found over time that this flexibility creates obstacles when we are trying to design scenarios or heroes who have a special deck that would be negatively affected by Cosmo’s ability. For that reason, we have decided to restrict Cosmo’s ability to only affecting player decks and the encounter deck, which still provides him a great deal of flexibility without standing in the way of new designs.

Taken from here: https://www.fantasyflightgames.com/en/news/2023/5/18/rules-reference-debrief-1/ 

Please, forget my report on [0.5.9.198]-hulk-winter_soldier-rhino-expert-(70)-(1685289210).json It was incorrect. 

Sorry for the inconvenience!

Hi,

Just a quick suggestion, in case you consider it interesting: would it be possible to implement the (homebrew) one-card hero fixes introduced here: https://www.reddit.com/r/marvelchampionslcg/comments/1pfsijv/onecard_hero_fixes_... I think they are simple, interesting ways of making some weak heroes more viable and fun to play. 

The set of cards (updated version) can be found here: https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1UmCrDEupOF_xp8s-R_2NSGWd_WFK7n3o

I totally understand that this should get a low priority in your schedule, but I'd be grateful if you just consider it, even for the future. 

Thanks in advance!  

Thanks so much!

You are right, you cannot use both of them, but I agree that you should be able to choose which one to use. Thanks in advance!

In this game [0.5.9.188]-bishop-magneto-expert-(123)-(1913490790).json, Wrapped in Metal (https://marvelcdb.com/card/32150) nwas attached to my identity. I should not be able to attack, but I was allowed to use Bishop's Rifle, which is an attack. 

Thanks in advance!

Hi, 

In this game [0.5.9.188]-bishop-en_sabah_nur-expert-(32)-(2124666301).json, I spent a double resource (yellow and red) to pay for the Blackout (https://marvelcdb.com/card/44053) ability. Only the red one was considered and, since there were already two red-resource places occupied, no threat was removed from the scheme. 

Thanks in advance!

Excellent, thank you!

Thanks so much!

Yeah, it also seemed strange to me. I understand that you want to keep it this way, even against the ruling, for consistency. Thanks!

Perfect, thank you!

Thanks so much!

Thanks so much!

The relevant piece of information comes from the rules (version 1.7) under the DISCARD entry: 

If a player looks at a number of cards from the top of a deck and discards one or more of those cards, those cards are considered to have been discarded from the top of that deck.

Thanks in advance! 

Oh, you are right. I didn't know about that rule. I thought overkill damage was dealt afterwards. Thanks for looking into it and sorry for the inconvenience!

As an additional example, consider Organizational Suport (https://marvelcdb.com/card/50014). The wording is "exhaust up to 3 allies and/or supports you control that share a Trait with your identity". Can you exhaust allies that you do not control or that do not share a trait with your identity? I do not think that is the intention of the card. 

Thanks once again!

Hi,

I have checked this with a Marvel Champion tester for FFG (that, specifically, was a tester for the SHIELD expansion) and he has confirmed that SHIELD applies to both the ally and the support. In fact, the official Spanish translation is like this: "Cuando se derrote esta carta: el jugador enfrentado descarta 1 Aliado o Apoyo S.H.I.E.L.D. que controle." Here, you can see that "SHIELD" is AFTER "Apoyo" (Support) so, if this trait were to be applied only to one of the two types of cards, we would have an inconsistency between the Spanish card and the English one (in Spanish, only the Support should be SHIELD; in English, only the ally). 

Thanks in advance!

Hi, thanks for looking into this. This has been ruled explicitly by FFG: 

189 – I have two questions regarding Magik’s ability to play the top card of her deck as if in hand: “Once per phase, you may play the top card of your deck as if it was in your hand, reducing its resource cost by 1.” 1. Can I play her ally Colossus in the villain phase from the top of her deck using his ability “Interrupt: When an enemy attacks you, play Colossus from your hand (paying his resource cost) and declare him the defender without exhausting him.”? 2. Can I play the top card of her deck with Team-Building Exercise: “Hero Action: Exhaust Team-Building Exercise → play a card from your hand that shares a trait with your hero, reducing its resource cost by 1.”?

Yes; using Magik’s ability, you can play Colossus (AOA #31) from the top of your deck during the villain phase and trigger his Interrupt ability. Yes; while playing a card from the top of your deck as Magik, it is considered to be “in your hand” for abilities such as Team-Building Exercise. (However, the card is not considered in your hand for other purposes, such as when you need to spend a resource or discard a card “from hand.”)

(Taken from here: https://hallofheroeslcg.com/latest-ffg-rulings-post-rrg-1-5/)

Thanks in advance!

Thanks so much!

Thanks so much!

Oh, yes, you are right. Thanks for looking into it and sorry for the inconvenience. 

Oh, yes, you are right. Thanks for looking into it and sorry for the inconvenience.  

Thanks so much!

Thanks so much!

Thanks so much!

Thanks so much!

Thanks so much!!!

Thanks so much!

OK, thanks for looking into it and sorry for the inconvenience!

OK, thanks for looking into it and sorry for the inconvenience!

OK, thanks for looking into it and sorry for the inconvenience!

Oh, OK, thanks for looking into it and sorry for the inconvenience.

Thanks so much!

Thanks so much. That really helps a lot!

Hi, 

In the last step of this savefile https://pastebin.com/V2dDBX4f (I uploaded it to Pastebin because I got an error 400 while trying to report it from the app), I played Shapeshifter Strike but my Shapeshiter upgrade was not readied. 

Thanks in advance! 

Yes, because Deft Focus and Friction Resistance are different types of cards. Deft Focus gives you an action that lets play a card at a discount. It is an action, so you need to activate the action and THEN play the card. Friction Resitance gives you a resource: you use it to pay for cards (or other things that require resources). Thus, you invoke it when you need to pay for something. In the case of playing cards, that is AFTER selecting the card to play. 

So what is implemented in the app is the correct way of using these cards. Even when playing physically, that is the correct order: first you select the card to play and then you generate the resources. 

I have just tried it and it works for me. For instance, in the following situation: 

Notice that you first need to select the card you want to play (Warlock, in this case) and then you select the resources. In this case, you can simply select the double resource card and Friction Resistance (notice that it has a circle with a red resource). 

Hope this helps!

Hi,

I've just tried this and it works correctly for me. You are given the option to apply the responses or not. For instance, with Weapons Training, you are presented with the following situation: 

If you do not want to ready the upgrades, you can either click on them to deselect them or click "End Response". 

Hope that helps!

In this game [0.5.9.188]-thor-hela-expert-(119)-(4947587).json, for some reason, Hela's ATK shows as 11 when it should be 1. 

Thanks in advance!