Yeah I think it's a problem between itch and Paypal. Another friend who uses itch was posting what happens when they try to use Paypal, and they're having issues too.. :S Hopefully it's something they get fixed soon!
Viewing post in PIXEL FANTASY RPG ICONS - PACK 17 comments
Ah! Just found a thread about it on itch's community board too. Seems like they're looking into it! :D