My game is fine on ratings but I've been keeping a list of some really good undiscovered games that have way less ratings than they deserve. I've been keeping them all (along with some properly rated ones) in a collection:
https://itch.io/c/1108916/miz-jam-1-favorites
Abandoned
This is a criminally underrated full-on Metroidvania game. It has a lot of cool powerups and progression and an expansive world. It also has amazing sound design and is really polished.
https://michael-grieshofer.itch.io/abandoned
Duck-like
Really well done rogue like topdown shooter with really engaging gameplay, I had a lot of fun with this one.
https://lukvargen.itch.io/ducklike
8 - Beat Dungeon
There are many "dungeon crawler rhythm games" submitted to this game jam, but of the ones I've played this is the most polished and fun. Instead of just being a normal rhythm game with the prompts reskinned to attacks, you actually get to choose your moves but have to do it to the beat.
https://nemopearwall.itch.io/8-beat-dungeon
Skull-a-mania
This is a solid bullet hell game with great art direction and sound design. It is a little short but I really enjoyed it.
https://dedhedzed.itch.io/skull-a-mania
Monster Casino
RPG with a pleasing visual style, good dialogue and a unique poker-based combat system with abilities