Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines
(+1)

Another question is: What is point of participating in a jam that would allow this as well?  It's not 'your' work per say.  It's something where the sources have been plundered from a global network of data without permission and used to generate some end result that may or may not be what was intended.  

  • What was gained?  Nothing.
  • What was learned?  Nothing.
  •  Are you any better as an artist or a coder after this?  No. 

This is a cheat used to 'generate' an end result to give you some advantage while the real workers struggle, fight and enjoy sleepless evening to put their damndest and best into their creations.  Maybe they look less impressive, but the creators come out stronger, smarter, faster, more effective, even if it is just a little piece at a time.  This AI use is not about working and improving oneself to becoming better.  It is about accomplishing absolutely nothing.

Not only do I see issues with claiming whose 'work' this is (which it is not), but I have ethical issues about the source of the 'work'.  Inspiration is one thing.  Taking the first three bass notes from an established music track because it got you thinking, then going off with it and create an entire different track is still a creation of yours.  Helping you get started is one thing, but something that does all the work accomplishes nothing in the end.  If you created your own version of pacman from the ground up after watching how the arcade version works, you created it.  You had to figure out the source code, including player movements, wall restrictions, pickup up pills and fruits, dealing with the ghosts, draw the pixels on the screen, make the sound effects.  You have learned and mastered some form of game-making ability and you should be proud of that! If you slapped the arcade code and resource file on itch and claimed it was our own, you have learned and gained nothing from this, and frankly, you should be ashamed of yourself.  In effect, this is what you did if you used AI for this: You slapped the arcade code and resource file on itch, plain and simple.

masterofgiraffe is spot on.  Even the giraffes would agree with such reasoning! 

So. Using your phone to take a picture is cheating too. You did not study years to perfect your painting skills, you used no canvas, did not mix your paints, yet you press a button and get an image anyway. You did not even need to select the light and shutter configuration or the focus for the picture. A cheat it is.

And yes, such images should not be entered in an oil painting jam. There are ai game jams for such things. And without surprise, most jams restrict ai usage in some way or compeletely. Especially, if it were a jam about learning to code.

If you created your own version of pacman from the ground up after watching how the arcade version works, you created plagiarized it.

Also, you very likely do not create it from the ground up. You will use libraries that other people programmed. You most likely will not write assembler, or even a low level language. In these times you will use a game engine. Probably Godot or Unity and create a game that is a modification of one of the tutorial games that has enough features that you can modify to look like a pacman type game.

And curiously no one takes issue with the fact that you just copied a known game idea. Without consent.

Hobby usage of ai is not the problem. It is an enabler. Just like using Godot and other engines are. Or even that scratch game site for kids. It enables people with little coding knowlege to create a game. And "little to no coding required" is one of the selling points of many game engines aimed at that market of hobby developers.

The problem is professional ai usage. AI assets. Games with a big budget, that chose to throw it away for ai tokens or said assets. Studios that could hire artists, but chose not to. And outisde of video games, all the ai hype and spam. Crap like an ai reading an ai script as a youtube video. That's even worse than those fake life hack videos from content farms. And problematic are the people that use ai to spam even more slop games, as they previously would have spammed with those no coding required engines.