Skip to main content

On Sale: GamesAssetsToolsTabletopComics
Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines

Let me turn this around. I don’t think Itch should tell you who is following you. Blocking a follower should be a complete non-issue because you shouldn’t know who your followers are in the first place.

I follow people because I want to be notified when they release or update projects. That’s it. I don’t do it to boost their egos or as an invitation to some kind of two-sided parasocial relationship. Telling the person I am following that I am following them feels like a violation of my privacy. And I am not violating their privacy because following them shouldn’t give me any information that isn’t already public.

(Technically following does give you access to information that only followers get in the form of game reviews, but that’s just another misfeature that I hate about Itch.)

Also:

I agree, if you block you have to block everything, it happened to me yesterday to block someone who after just one minute of registering on the site came to follow me, it seemed suspicious to me and I immediately blocked him,But I keep seeing it in the people who follow me, even if I’d like to delete it I can’t.

Sorry, what’s suspicious about that situation? Person comes to Itch and hangs out for some time. After browsing for some time, person wants to follow someone. Person realizes that they need an account to follow someone, so they create an account and hit the follow button immediately afterwards. If you think that’s suspicious, then maybe Itch should allow you to opt out of being followed at all.

You're right, in fact I apologized...

(2 edits) (+1)

The moment you can interact with me on the site, of course I’ll want to know. Otherwise it’s like being stalked by a creep. You know why? Because then you could use my feed to interact with me in a systematic way. In other words, to harass me. And when you follow me? I have no way of knowing for how long you’ve been doing it without an account. If you don’t at least leave a comment first or something? See above. That’s instantly sus.

At least blocking on itch.io prevents people from directly replying to your posts and comments. That’s very useful. It should do even more.

See, the thing is that I don’t think “following” someone counts as an interaction. I’m interaction with Itch, not with you. Same as when I watch somebody on TV, or read a magazine article about someone. Itch made it into an interaction, by giving you access to your list of followers, and by giving followers some extra information that non-followers don’t get. Both of which are bad ideas, IMO.

Look at the things I can do without following. I can visit your profile page and see your recent posts. I can bookmark your profile page and look at it every day. I can see your creator page. If I really wanted to harass you, I would already have all of the information I need. I wouldn’t even need an account!

For that matter, think about how easy it would be to follow someone with one account while using another account to harass them, and how easy it is to lie on the internet. The way to be “safe” is to accept no followers.

I follow people because I want to hear about it when they create new works, because there’s a decent chance that I would enjoy those works or find them useful. That’s it. It’s the equivalent of bookmarking their creator page, but without having to check that page manually. I follow without posting a message first precisely because I don’t want to interact with them. (Not because I don’t like them, but because I am just not very social by nature.) I don’t even care if they block me, so long as this does not stop me from buying their stuff. But who I am following is not public information, and I don’t want it to be used against me.

Harassment is a serious problem, but making it slightly less convenient to access public information is not an effective way of dealing with it.

But I absolutely agree that blocking should be stronger.

Technically following does give you access to information that only followers get in the form of game reviews

there is a privacy setting for this.

Make my public activity on itch.io visible to my followers and other users of the site
Public activity includes things like adding games to a public collection, publishing a game, submitting to a jam, rating a public game.

you can only follow things that appear in the global feed. 

New projects Posts Collections Ratings

keeping followers hidden would make sense for pure publisher accounts. but all publishers here are users too, and all users might publish things. anyone can curate a public collection. and for users on social media, it is normal to see who is following you.

i wonder how it is on steam. those accounts are publisher only accounts.