UPDATED RATING AFTER REPLAYING THE GAME:
Enjoyment: 4/5
I somehow completely missed the cup part in the tutorial the first time </3 that's my bad. The game is actually very fun once you get the hang of things! I wish there was a bit more variety in the gameplay, the little conditions are cool, but I feel like there could be more impactful ones, maybe even having different ingredients be prepared in different methods rather than just being heated up.
Creativity and Theme: 4/5
My opinion on this aspect didn't really change. Spinning the potions is cool but the fact you end up just being able to shake them instead is a bit odd.
Visuals: 4/5
Same as what I said earlier, they're good, but some little animations would make them even better!
Audio: 3/5
Again, no BGM hurts this a lot, but that's understandable from what you've told me.
Seriousness: 4/5
Ok yeah, the game has more serious elements that it initally met my eye, bonus seriousness point!
FINAL RATING: 4/5
Cool entry! I feel like it lacks a bit of gameplay variety, but it has a strong idea. Thank you for letting me know what i had originally missed and pushing me towards giving the game a 2nd chance! :D