HEY I did some experimenting and found something. Try this; -"Actually, yeah, there's alot wrong" -"A wine bottle," -"Because I can get you something you want in exchange." -"Caine Atheron is missing," -Do you want him to be? -Because no one else will -i thought you didnt want him to be found
Hey! By any chance, At the 'crimson rouge's side exit.' did you go right and pick up the pin? If you did, I think that was the issue, you have to go left and eavesdrop the convo! It should work now. If thats not the issue, let me know and I'll keep searching!