Looks great!
Highlights:
- Taking on an injury or a flaw is a nice way to lean into the pirate genre
- The use of public domain art
Constructive Criticism:
- The Meet the Pirates section coming before the The Rules section means that a reader is either looking at the characters with little context for what most of their stuff means, or they're flipping past the characters to learn how the game works before flipping back.
- A couple of different fonts might help the graphic design evoke the era, like a distressed font for display text and a serif font for body text.