Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines
(1 edit) (+1)

I liked your story.

Your worldbuilding is pretty cool. It reminded me of the anime "Frieren" at first, from its style & thematics. The best thing to me was your interpretation of magic. That basically every dream of someone is caused by magic.. or a perception of magic. This was also a good introduction to the sorcerer.

I think you can trust your audience a little more to connect the pieces. After that "Crub still thought about the question of the sorcerer", you take too much time (for my taste) to tell the reader "on-the-nose" that there is a sorcerer. You are obviously very talented in inventing fantastic & magical stuff. The images in this story are truly innovative. But for a short story, you take a little too much pride & time in describing your stuff. The description of only the sorcerers physical appearance (which IS awesome) took around a quarter of the whole story.

I liked the idea of the Giant's Pines, but the timing to introduce them couldn't have been worse: the hero just presented his problem of insecurity. The tension was growing. And then you introduced those Pines, which stabilize the whole world & give a feeling of security & orientation.

So: worldbuilding, magic & creativeness are your definite strengths. The story tells about inner conflict & bravery. Even teaches a little lesson, which is great. Please keep those skills. Get your understanding of atmosphere right, so you can build it up instead of breaking it. Restrict your pride a little (hard for me too). Then I can see unimaginable fantasy-stories come out of your fingers.

Thank you very much for the detailed comment! This was my first story and your feedback helps a lot. When adding the Pines in that moment, I was trying to give the character some "grounding"; otherwise, I would have felt like Crub agreeing to become a hero would be somewhat unjustified within the story, since up to that point I had only focused on showcasing that it was chaotic and dangerous, but now that I read it again it does feel out of place... 

I will definitely work on restricting the pride; I personally really like long descriptions of stuff, but I definitely need to work on integrating actual story into it.

Again, thank you for the detailed reply!!!

Deleted 19 days ago
(1 edit) (+1)

I have the feeling, if you put the introduction of the Pines right after the magic-intro & before the introduction of the sorcerer, the atmospheric flow would work better. especially if you sprinkle one short description of the world in, which feels dangerous or unsettling (in the "you can see the pines from everywhere, whether from A, whether from B, whether from the villages where life was completely replaced by unimaginable horrors, whether from D" part.)

But that's just my personal taste. maybe try it out & see if you like it or not :)

Now that I think about it, that does make sense; Tension wise definitely, I should have put the Pines before, but even in terms of worldbuilding, earlier introduction of the Pines would work better. This jam has been a very good learning opportunity lol