Did you not press the "Next Camper" button on the billboard? As soon as you "catch" the camper the next camper button should appear on the board.
Viewing post in Camp Trustfall jam comments
Yeah, I struggled with the best way to implement "start and next" I probably should have just had it float in front of the player as a 3D UI object on top of all the geometry in the scene similar to the Win and Fail UI, but I built that first and then I didn't want to go back and change it and couldn't think of a more elegant way to handle it and well it is what it is. Ideally, I would have the characters follow a navmesh with waypoints and walk up there themselves but that was beyond the scope of the jam.