My main issue with morality games that kind of force you down the evil path is that you're not making much of a choice. Especially for something like this, unless you honestly want to click 12.6k times and risk getting carpal tunnel. Despite the VA guy's sincerity with his lines, I am not feeling the guilt for doing this in less clicks.
I would love the option to take non-hurty shop items and get a small increase but still a much slower dollars per click gain compared to the dangerous stuff, or even click back down weapons which the british VA guy seems to imply you can do in his dialogue. Which you can't. That way players are absolutely making a choice of disfiguring and murking an innocent man.