I was a big fan of this game until I ended up in an unwinnable state twice after lengthy playthroughs.

The puzzles are often illogical (eg, stealing from people or rowing out to sea for no reason), buggy (eg, old man and the item you show him has a trigger issue), or broken (eg, forced to drop an item that cannot be retrieved, see here for it happening to somebody else: https://intfiction.org/t/anchorhead-2018-elevator/14090).

The atmosphere, story, and characters are 11/10.