I'm only giving it a three star out of mercy. I wanted to give a two. The only reason its even a two is the music and art are lovely. I wanted to like this buuuuttt its just .... not enough to be a game. Its advertised as make potions but its really just clicking thorough dialouge, making one potion more dialouge, one potion and so on. if it ever ramps up later than the flaw is that it doesnt just immediately do so. It makes more sense to do the intro and then just immediately have the player doing potions and just keep being given new potion order after completion and the next day starting after doing a certain amount. Increase the number of poitions with time and do scenes to introduce new ingredients and just keep playing. But this is really just a point and click visual novel which isnt a game about making potions. Its just two witches chatting and also theres some beeswax on a shelf essentially. Its unfortunate. I really did want to like this one