I'll come back and edit this review once it's been played at my table (may be a long time), but for the moment:

Between a rather original idea (time loops themselves are not, Truman Show-esque setups are not, but combining the two is); a sleek, efficient layout; and all the right tools in all the right amounts, Replay is an instant addition to my MoSh oneshot repertoire. My only minor complaint (that, all things being equal, I would probably not choose a sloth as my Big Bad for a TV show) is easily remedied by Warden fiddling and therefore cannot be held against the pamphlet.