Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines

[HELP] [LEGAL] [TECHNICAL] Can my game legally block task manager on Windows?

A topic by Chajimo created 10 days ago Views: 179 Replies: 4
Viewing posts 1 to 3

Hello,

First of all, I would like to apologize if there are any mistakes, I am French and I am translating this message with Google Translate.

I want to create a psychological horror game that breaks the fourth wall (like Doki Doki Literature Club for example), and in the title screen of my game, I would like to make it so that the player is forced to use the "QUIT" button on the title screen, preventing them from closing the game in any other way (there will still be some emergency solutions, but little known to most users).

I know that I can legally remove the cross at the top of the window since it is directly an element that belongs to my program, and also that I can close the command prompt since it does not require administrator rights.

But the remaining problem is the task manager. To close it, you need administrator rights, and after doing some research, although it's not illegal in France, I learned that it is illegal in some countries like the United States, and that game sharing sites like itch.io prohibit it.

So I was wondering: what exactly is illegal about this? Is it closing a system-protected application, or preventing the use of the task manager, regardless of whether it's closed with administrator rights or otherwise?

Because if it's only closing a Windows-protected application that's prohibited, I planned to just make the window move to the task manager in "always on top" mode, which shouldn't require administrator rights, the problem with that is just that the user could open a second window further away from the first.

Also, I don't know if it's important to mention, but the program only blocks the use of the task manager on the title screen; nothing will be blocked during the rest of the game, so the effect is only temporary and does NOTHING (normally) damage the computer.

Blocking the task manager isn't illegal in itself.

What is illegal is doing it without the user's consent. Furthermore, this type of behavior is typically associated with malicious programs, so your application will trigger antivirus software, be blocked, and possibly quarantined by Itch.

You might think it's a good idea and a great way to break the fourth wall, but trying to limit the basic functionality of someone else's computer is rude. There's no justification for doing so, and in the long run, it will only cause you problems.

Why should anyone trust you to block basic security components of their computer?

All you're doing is raising suspicions and raising concerns that will lead to your program being flagged as malware.

I can't disagree. If something is loading the computer, for example, and you need to use the task manager to close it, the user won't be able to do that. The only option is to force restart or shut down the computer, which can cause a lot of controversy. I believe this is a justified concern

Ok, thanks for the answers.

So I understood that preventing the operation or access to task manager was not a good idea and risked classifying my game as malware (even if that is not its purpose).

But could simply preventing task manager from closing my program, without preventing the user from using task manager to close other programs besides mine, could be a good solution?

If there is indeed a program other than mine on the user's PC that stops working, takes up too many resources, and the user needs to close it with the task manager because for some reason they cannot do so via the close button (which is a problem I hadn't really thought of), then the user will still be able to close it, and the use of the task manager is not blocked, so I think it should be fine and that itch should not block my game and that the antivirus should leave my program alone (well, I hope so).

(2 edits)

This is still malicious behavior. I will not name games that used such and similar "features" and were previously on the platform like steam, and itch.io. Ironically, they no longer exist, 'cause platforms removed them. You HAVE NOT permission to use this features, 'cause it's breaking many of terms, and breaking user's safety and privacy. Let me give an example: maybe your game not so destructive, but virus can infect it. So, what player gonna do at this moment? Right. He can't do anything, 'cause author of the game turned off permission to close it. I recommend to think again about it