Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines

adrianmoli

4
Posts
2
Topics
A member registered 15 days ago

Creator of

Recent community posts

Quick blunt pass: the page already feels reasonably trustworthy to me, but it still asks the downloader to infer too much about install risk.

For an existing Godot project, the first screen should answer these before the long pitch:

- Which Godot versions are supported.

- Exact install path / folder structure.

- Whether it touches project.godot, InputMap, autoloads, save files, or editor settings.

- How to uninstall or remove it cleanly.

- What the free/pay-what-you-want download includes.

- A 30-second import -> run GIF, ideally before feature screenshots.

The phrase "demo shell" is good, but I would add a tiny "safe to inspect first" block near the download button:

"Plain Godot scenes + GDScript. No Steamworks dependency. No save framework replacement. Includes QA checklist and build-stamp hook."

That would make the download feel much safer because it names the boundaries. Right now the page sells the benefits well, but trust comes from saying what it does NOT do.

For the install path specifically, I would show one concrete example:

1. Copy/addons/demo_shell/

2. Open demo_shell_demo.tscn

3. Map your feedback/store URLs

4. Run included smoke-test scene

So my answer: yes, it is close enough to download, but I would move "install safety / boundaries / uninstall" above some of the marketing copy.

Hi! I think the "amateurish" feeling is less about one bad element and more about the UI system not being strict enough yet.

What stands out to me:

- The fantasy title font is strong, but it is doing too many jobs. Buttons, small labels, numbers, shop text, and headings all have similar visual weight, so the eye has trouble knowing what matters first. I would keep the decorative font for titles and primary CTAs, then use a cleaner readable font for small labels/prices/body text.

- The gold/brown border treatment repeats everywhere at almost the same strength. Level cards, shop panels, inventory slots, buttons, and HUD boxes all compete. Pick one "primary panel" style, then make secondary cards thinner, darker, or lower contrast.

- Alignment feels loose. The menu buttons, level cards, shop, inventory, and confirm button do not feel like they come from the same grid. A simple 8/16 px spacing system would help a lot.

- Some contrast is too low: "No penalties", item prices, small level notes, and disabled buy buttons blend into the dark background. Push important text brighter and make disabled states more obviously disabled.

- The icons feel like different icon sets. Coin, scissors, chisel, gear, and tile symbols use different rendering/line-weight languages. Redrawing or recoloring them into one consistent silhouette style would make the whole UI feel more professional fast.

Quick fix I would try first: reduce the floating background shapes behind menu/UI screens, brighten the panel fill slightly, thin the secondary borders, standardize button sizes, and reserve the fantasy font for title/primary actions.

The base art direction is solid. It mostly needs hierarchy and consistency, not a total redesign.

Hi! I'm offering a small, focused review-mining and store-page triage service for itch.io creators.

For the $5 intro version, I'll read your project page plus public comments/reviews if available, compare the page against similar itch.io projects, and send a concise action list.

You get:

- 5 likely blockers or missed opportunities

- title/tag/short-description suggestions

- screenshot/download/CTA suggestions

- 3 quick fixes to try first

Best fit:

- small games, demos, asset packs, tools, and jam projects

- creators who want practical feedback before pushing for more traffic

I will not post fake reviews, manipulate ratings, or spam your project. This is analysis only.

Reply with your itch.io project link if you want a quick paid triage.

Example of the kind of asset/page I'm working around:

https://adrianmoli.itch.io/tiny-commerce-ui-48-pixel-icons-for-shop-inventory-ga...

Hi! I just released Tiny Commerce UI, a small CC0 pixel-art asset pack with 48 icons for shop, inventory, crafting, and management-game menus.

It includes individual transparent PNGs, a ready-to-slice 8x6 sprite sheet, and a free sampler.

Useful for cozy shop games, RPG inventories, game jam prototypes, and small management games.

Link:

https://adrianmoli.itch.io/tiny-commerce-ui-48-pixel-icons-for-shop-inventory-ga...