Have to say, both versions seem like they have a different vibe. The RPG Maker sort of seemed like a more grounded Silent Hill, while the 3D version has this sort of abstract, dreamlike feel. I like both, but it really does seem that the 3D version inspired you more and you did put more work into it, so it's clearly the better option here.
I'm looking forward to whatever this project ends up being once it finishes!
Viewing post in Solace Creek - Jumping to 3D comments
I think you're spot on. In the beginning of a project I'm still figuring out a lot of things direction wise. Like the tone, gameplay and things like that.
And the 2d version was definitely more grounded with some lighter dream-like elements and a more upfront story. Where the 3d version leans a bit more into the surreal dreamy elements. I also wanted to explore different ways in telling a story - not only through dialogue and cutscenes so it'll definitely have a slightly different tone and vibe :)
Thank you so much for sticking around and I can't wait for you to try out the upcoming preview version!