Not sure what the endings are, I only get the one where I open my eyes after picking all his features and he isn't there. He's too nice to kill you, right? When does he kill you???
He killed me after I picked all the features, he forced my eyes open and then killed me. I picked lost eyes, tired hands and surprised grimace. I never once opened my eyes EXCEPT when he DEMANDED it. But he just forced them open even if I said I'd open them. I wonder if there's a good end.