It was interesting. I thought I chose wrong in the beginning, but there was not shooting, only slapping after all. I slapped them all then. I would have liked the movement to be on the left hand like in with the handheld. No music :-(
Sorry about the shotgun not working during your playthrough it must've been annoying using melee only. I didn't even think of adding left handed movement options but next time I will be sure to allow more control options.