After getting the Sage for the girl, you have to go rest? So I looked for Elisha's house, found Elisha and Clair's house, but you can't move in there. So you're pretty much stuck. I am pretty sure this isn't intended.
Almost forgot, Faith asks for Slime Jelly, however even when you have Slime Jelly, when talking to her, she still tells you to talk to her when you have Slime Jelly. (Tried with 1 jelly, 2 jelly, 3 jelly... up to 7 jelly.)