Hikiyami! Thank you so much! I watched the whole video (almost 3 hours hahaha) and I really appreciate all the feedback.
There are definitely many aspects that could have been better and I understand the tone shift from pure horror to dark comedy horror might not be everyone's cup of tea (and the fart jokes are too much), but as you mentioned, there's the risk of making the exact same game again (and then you get accused of making the same game) and sometimes it's hard live up to the previous version. I took a gamble and I guess people will be divided regarding the jokes and the tone shift. I'll definitely go back to pure horror for my next project.
Nevertheless, your feedback is really valuable and I will certainly keep it in mind for future projects! And I will certainly never use that mirror sound effect again hahahaha
Here are some clarifications:
-the paintings are not references to anyone, I was just messing around with paint and came up with whatever crossed my mind, but I guess they could be family members who lived in another house
-the hat not disappearing is actually a bug, but it could also be that the puppet forgot to take it
-the lamp in the basement is a reference to the lamp ending from the first game
-the ghostly clock was needed so that the worshipper tells you the time (12:30), so then you tell that number to cousin Marietta. But you solved the puzzle earlier than expected hahaha
-Greta is not a floating head hahaha, she's just wearing a pitch black dress. At times, you can see her arms and hands
-Thalassophobia was supposed to be represented in the mermaid's cave, but I guess it didn't work as intended
-the mini bobs and rotten Alesas are not real enemies, they said random things. The rotten Alesa creature is supposed to represent what Alesa will become if she marries Mr. Bob
I'm probably forgetting something but anyway
Thanks again for the playthrough and your feedback! I really enjoyed the video!