Ahh, there you go. You missed the most important part of the game, which is the 2nd stage and the ending. You could have pushed yourself a bit further, because the controls on the 2nd stage are far less terrible than the platformer one.
I would also like to point out here that sometimes it isn’t nice to give a very poor score on someone’s game if you quit prematurely because you could have missed a lot of important details. It sometimes would be considered as disrespecting the developer, especially since they have worked hard on their games, going through the pain on the bug fixes and the intense programs they have to produce. Imagine if someone actually did that, published it, only to have people making rants against it, yeah, it’s easy to tell that the developer can feel very bad, and even regret making that game. Just because people give feedback doesn’t mean it’s going to do any good, and just because you can do something doesn’t mean you should do it; there are bad people out there who gives harsh comments impulsively.
I’m not saying that you give a bad feedback or feedback and criticism is bad, though, what I’m saying is that we should all sometimes view the full contents of the program before giving feedback, while giving respect with words of encouragement to improve later on.
I played both of your games, and your content definitely has a lot less than mine, no offense, but I still give you a score higher than a 5 on both of them, while you gave me a 3/10.
In my game, I worked pretty hard at the 2nd stage and the ending cutscene, as I give a big emotional tunes into it.
It is important to elaborate on what you give feedback, and then bring your thoughts together for your final speech.
However, I still appreciate your feedback about the slippery controls on the 1st stage, because I do have to find another engine to use. Although, finding a really good, flawless, and responsive Sonic engine is very difficult, which is why a lot of Sonic engines on Scratch aren’t that good. I have to use what I got, but feedback is still needed either way.
I’m not mad at you or anything. I‘m just giving you some advice so that next time, you can view full contents on another person’s game, and then give your final thoughts to it as a whole, while giving encouragement to improve later on in the future, WITHOUT hurting or triggering the feelings of others. Just saying…
And speaking of feelings, don’t feel bad about yourself for sharing your incomplete experience. We all make mistakes here, and what matters the most is that we all learn from our own mistakes. Even I make mistakes as well. I know most of us seen adults, yet, so what matters the most is the effort we put into our games, and then rethink about the mistakes we make so that we can improve in the future. It takes time, but we’ll get through it.