I tried YAGS, but it wasn't really my thing. I think the art style was the most off-putting thing to me. I may try it again later and try to get past the art. It's not bad, just not my cup of tea.
Some games have horrific art but lovely plots.
I liked EBAE, but again it was a bit short for me.
Personally, I like building relationships in most games; In other words, no sex right off the bat lol. However, some of those have a nice concept to them.
In Charles 2.0, the sex made sense to me because the relationships were pre-existing.
I don't expect you to compromise your vision of your games based on my own opinions, either. Regardless of preference, I've enjoyed most of the ones you've done.
Also, I have Blood and Lust that I'll be playing soon.