Skip to main content

On Sale: GamesAssetsToolsTabletopComics
Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines
(+1)

Sorry, I'd appreciate an introduction / conclusion for this. I skimmed thru but didn't get what you are trying to convey. It'd be helpful for us who don't (yet) hav time to read the whole thing.

And is "Bara" really a widely used term for contents such as Tagame's work? For me "Bara" means the same as "YAOI".
But then I've no idea what terms to use other than "Gay" / "Gay focused". And you mentioned "Bara" ain't actually mean "Gay contents for gay audiences, often Muscular", since you differentiate "Bear" from "Bara". Now I'm all confused. >_<

(+1)

I guess I should put a TL;DR somewhere. But to answer your question, "bara" doesn't have a clear meaning but usually refers to drawn sexualized depictions of traditionally-masculine men. Yes, it's often used to describe what type of story it is, usually indicating that it sexualizes men who are muscular or have non-mainstream bodies. 

To explain the difference between bara and yaoi, I'd have to explain what yaoi is briefly. Essentially it is a genre of manga and anime that focuses on a male same-sex relationship that's typically made by women for women. The term then began to be used for any story that focused on a male same-sex relationship even if it didn't come from Japan. However, due to marketing and audience, stories that are usually labeled as "yaoi" or "BL" (which more or less mean the same thing except "yaoi" usually depicts more sexual stories) usually contain pretty-looking, young men as the focus. There have been "yaoi" that includes more muscular characters or older characters, but they're pretty rare. The lack of a clear definition of "yaoi" and "BL" is actually kind of a problem for some Manga and Anime such as Yuri On Ice!!! and Ao no Flag that features gay characters (although some people argue that Yuri on Ice!!! just implies it which I'm not getting into) and people call them "yaoi" when they don't fit the genre. "yaoi" is definitely not the same as "bara" but which is which depends on what the artist calls it really. Some say their work is "yaoi", some say it's "bara", and some say it's both. But generally, I'd recommend not calling a gay VN that has slender characters "bara" or a gay comic that has musclechub characters "yaoi". People have expectations when it comes to these terms so not caring about how you use these terms shows that you are very ignorant about these terms. It's like calling Khloe Kardashian "goth" because she wore black one time or a cute anime girl "a tomboy" because she has short hair. Yeah, these terms don't have exact definitions but that's no excuse for using these words for whatever.

Essentially, there are no clear definitions of "bara" and "yaoi" but most people expect muscular/beefy, sexualized gay men with "bara" and slender, pretty men with "yaoi". Whether or not something is bara, yaoi, or both depends on the creator.

As for the difference between "bear" and "bara", "bear" refers to a specific subgenre of the gay community or a gay man who's hairy. "bara" usually refers to fictional men since the proportions of the bodies tend to be really exaggerated. However "bara" can be used to describe real-life men if they are particularly buff or beefy, though I personally don't do this. Basically, there is a lot of overlap with the two terms, but not all bears are "bara" as not all bears are muscular, and not all bara feature "bears" since not all bara depict hairy men.

Thx for the trouble. So they're actually not terms which agreed upon (is why I'm still confused)?

Your 'Bara' is more of fictional '筋肉男' (exaggerated muscular men), while it can still mean '薔薇' (aka 'Yaoi'), or just for fictional gay in general?
So when one see those terms used, one still needs to look into the context to know which they are referring to?

And it all boils down to if the targeted audiences are female or gay men?
There was a critique I used to determine:  "Love focused" is for the former; "Sex focused" is for the latter. 

But (not sure still waiting the TL:DR or hving time to read :P) what you try to do is generalising the use of "Bara" as a theme / type (just like 'bear'), that not necessarily means Erotic / Porn / Sex / NSFW contents?

(+1)

Yup. There's no clear definition for either of these terms. It depends on who you ask on whether or not there can be overlap between bara and yaoi, or if something can be both bara and yaoi at the same time. I personally don't think there's overlap but I also don't think everything that focuses on a gay couple and isn't a yaoi is bara. Heartstopper isn't a yaoi or BL, but I wouldn't call it bara. I'd say it's just a gay-themed comic. And I'm not going to dismiss anyone who describes their work as both yaoi and bara although I would tell them that they should go with one or the other if they're friends of mine. Generally speaking, yaoi is for both women and gay men (with more focus on women) while bara is usually only for gay men and is more overtly sexual. For me, I feel like the way people use the word "bara" is quite broad that I can't really put a strict definition for it. And people do describe SFW material as bara (Is Minotaur Hotel suddenly not bara when you play the game on SFW mode?) so I don't consider being NSFW a requirement to be bara.

Well I didn't label it as TL;DR because I think a proper TL;DR would be quite long XD, but here's what I was talking about when I talked about putting in a "TL;DR"

"All in all, bara is a word that describes the sexualization of men that are muscular, beefy, and/or hairy for the benefit of gay men. It can tell many gay stories that the mainstream cannot tell due to not being afraid of showing the perspectives and tastes of gay men that aren't young and conventionally attractive. It is a wonderful thing that has plenty of potential, but it can also be used poorly. We should strive to develop our community so we can reach greater lengths with bara."

(+1)

I get it now. Thanks. And I totally agree! (Guess I was one of those who took it for granted XD)

Maybe I needn't stress over those terms that much. People have different preferences, especially for Sex Appeal, it's personal and specific. So we should embrace while respect the Variety - might took more effort to create / find the contents we are looking for, but we should be grateful that we can have these choices in the first place.

Also saw you mentioned Minotaur Hotel, I'm glad you ain't excluding Furry as part of it :P (Actually you already mentioned Nanoff's & Rausmutt's work in your main post XD)

Personally I consume these kind of contents for the NSFW part, so it's great when they go beyond sex (like your work :P)