always wanted more mario combat since i first played it, but i never thought it'd be like this!
you seemed to insinuate in the gallery's dev room that you don't have very much of an idea on where you want the future updates to go, so hopefully these will help out:
- gameplay loop kinda gets boring after a while.
my first playthrough was an absolute trip, blared punk rock and had an amazing time, but the subsequent playthroughs i had directly after weren't quite as interesting.
i think adding some kind of combo system and a visible score on the HUD would make it a bit more fun for repeat playthroughs,
uppercutting and basically dribbling the enemies around the map is fun and all, but it's so overpowered that it's all you really need to do for a lot of the game,
having a combo system that rewards fancier or more varied moves would make the game a lot more fun and replayable,
and having your score be visible throughout the entire game, basically letting the player know what gives them more points, and letting them know if they're doing well,
would probably be very helpful in making shooting for high-scores feel worthwhile
- maybe have some more enemy AI variety?
i found it really easy to just group all the enemies in a map together and just uppercut-dribble them around any maps with low enough ceilings.
maybe have a couple of the more special enemies, like the syringe dudes, kind of keep their distance from you a little while other enemies are attacking you so you can't do that as easily?
on the topic of enemy variety, i think having more varied attacks would be nice,
the traffic cone dudes and the generic vanilla pudding dudes just felt practically the same, could maybe make one of the enemy types jump at you to make them be less predictable?
- i wanna play as the puro transfur that;d be awesome!!!
you could probably make it a reward for getting all the endings or reaching a certain point in the wave mode which would make either feel more worthwhile
also giving him an eye shine trail like the snow leopard chase sequence would look cool as hell
- keep adding subtitles to the game's name every time you update it so it eventually becomes something ridiculous like "Changed: Berserk Deluxe: Special Edition: Revised: The Definitive Edition: The Complete Edition: Director's Cut" lol
- a multiplayer mode would be awesome!
Funny_Approved in the comment directly below mine mentioned an emote mechanic, which would work well with multiplayer too
- keybinds!
some players either don't have working keys or just don't like using the up arrow key to jump.
i had broken/sticky arrow keys, and had to bind a lot of games to the I, J, K, and L keys for so long that it became a personal preference for me, even long after i bought a new keyboard
...just make sure you can always use the arrow keys to control things, just in case the player messes something up or in case they re-bind the jump key (so that you don't have to hit the X key to go up in a menu lol)
- controller support
i personally don't mind (and actually prefer) using my keyboard over a controller,
but a lot of people really prefer controllers, and it'd make the game a bit more accessible
- more guns!!!
having a pistol (i think a beretta m9 would make realistic sense) for a more common and less powerful ranged weapon would be fun
desert eagle would be unrealistic, but fun,
an smg, like an mp5 or an uzi would be fun
the way colin holds the guns is kind of weird,
and the way he just one-hands them while shooting is absolutely ridiculous and awesome looking and i love it please never change that
also the full auto of the AK doesn't really feel as fun and impactful as it should,
though if you feel that a full-auto gun would be too overpowered you could just go with a larger 3-round burst instead
there's also just not enough spawn-points for them throughout the game?
there's only one at the very end, aside from the ones found randomly in lockers
- cheats system!
having infinite ammo/health/weapon health cheats would be fun unlockables and would give you more incentive to play extra modes
having a cheat that gave you more guns, or a cheat that gave you an inventory system so you could hold multiple weapons would be cool
- more modes / wave mode changes
maybe you could make a mode dedicated to platforming? seeing as the extra modes aren't really canon, they don't really have to make much sense
maybe something along the lines of smash bros' break the targets?
the platforming physics are SUPER satisfying, and they're not used quite as extensively as i think they should be
on the topic of extra modes, the wave mode's kind of boring?
i think having more variety in the areas themselves would help out a little, having more platforms, a few larger arenas, and maybe some stage hazards would be fun,
and having an outdoors area like the on the side of the building near the end of the game would be pretty cool
- the items feel kind of same-y?
the crowbar, axe, and pipe really don't feel all that different
it's not a PROBLEM, but it's something else you could work on
- i personally find the quote-unquote "broken" english extremely charming,
and there aren't any errors that make any of the text completely incomprehensible,
but i could probably help localize it if you want???
- walljump from the original game would be fun,
i know this isn't as platforming based as the original, but the walljump would be an interesting addition to the game
- more bosses would be nice
pretty sure you already mentioned a puro fight (a more one-on-one, ),
but i think some of changed special's bosses would work well as bosses here, like the wolf king, or the big-boy-300-gallon-amalgamate bosses would be fun,
- the shark dudes / squid dog dude not having dedicated transfurs, and just continually beating the hell out of you after you die is kind of weird
- i want to pet puro
- more alternate paths?
- the endings don't really feel very impactful, or final? (aside from ending 1)
i think having a second boss fight after the squid dog would be fun, though i already mentioned boss fights before
- i wanna break more stuff!!!
i think having more boxes, furniture like desks and tables,
and maybe having more stuff you could pick up and throw like the traffic cones would be fun, i think chairs and boxes would work nicely
...and that's all i have for right now!
sorry if it feels like a text block, or if my personality's a bit obnoxious, or (especially) if this was hard to translate.
i don't do quite enough long-form writing like this, so it's probably a little amateur.
i haven't used itch.io's comment system before, hopefully i can edit this later to make it a bit better than it is (edit: yes i can)