Back then, I enjoyed several things in playing this game. As has already been said, it is a very "contemplative" and relaxing game, habitual but in a positive sense, because it makes you step into the role of the protagonist and makes your imagination fly a bit.
I think you hit the theme of the contest well, in particular I appreciated the New Game Plus as it was justified by the plot (with some little gems like the upgrades).
In short, nice, well done.
I really like the graphics, especially the customized sprites in different movements, a little less the portraits, not so much for the similar faces but for the bust that seems a little too small compared to the face. Maybe it was a choice of style, but let's say that given the realistic style of the faces it makes me a little out of place.
I loved the alternative mechanics, from the shop, to cleaning and weeding plants. I loved that Farmer slacker and hated that fool who minded my own business while I just wanted to go out and get killed in the night xD
Very nice Maggie story too, I think the game gives what it promises
[SPOILER] I have two endings, the one where Maggie lends us the amulet and the one where Phina does the ritual by herself. Cute!