I think the idea is really quirky, and I think there's a lot of charm here. I'm not entirely convinced by the execution.
This feels like a game the right person could lose months of their lives to. Anyone who loves Animal Crossing, Harvest Moon, Stardew Valley, or maybe even Monster Rancher to an extent will fall in love with this. I think my main problem is I'm not really one for those games either. Just a case of not my thing.
Graphically, there's a really nice cohesion. Everything's very vibrant and colourful. All of the assets look like they blong together. I particularly love the windowskin. Little touches like text boxes appearing by the person speaking is something I've always liked to see since my first playthrough of Final Fantasy IX. The font is a perfect match for the tone of the game while retaining legibility.
The presentation is let down by the mugshots, I'd honestly like to see them redrawn. They currently give off a vibe of 13 year old making an honest attempt to learn to draw, that might even be the case for all I know. The title screen is also crying out for a graphic designer.
Overall, while it didn't match my personal tastes, I think what you've made here is a solid foundation and I'd be interested in seeing you build upon it. Good job.