Rating the game based on the judges' categories for fun
Gameplay
This was really confusing at first even after reading the game page for the controls, since none of the table functions are explained. I also got a little bit stuck in the flavor selection screen since there is no indication that you needed to use the spacebar to choose them. After some fiddling, I figured out what was the objective of the game
The game needs a lot more feedback, both in visuals and sound. It was easy to see since I was playing alone, but the cones should tell you which flavors are in them at the moment. There should also be an indication of success or failure when you deliver the final ice cream, as well as something that clearly tells you which order you fulfilled (like for example an animation of the order moving away from the screen)
I can imagine this being fun when played with friends, but it lacks polish
[10/20] -> Doubled to 20
Presentation
The pixel graphics were cute and well done, although I feel that there is a lot of empty space in the screen sometimes
Sound was nonexistent and it was really needed to set up the frantic atmosphere of the game
Overall, I felt not much is explained to the player through the visuals, other than the absolute basics of the game mechanics
[10/20]
Engagement
The lack of initial direction and the need to have 4 players for the core experience hurts this game in this area. The timer also felt pretty long, but maybe it was because I was playing alone. Overall I didn't really feel like playing another round
[6/20]
Potential
As indie games go, you have a seriously heavy competition in Overcooked. I know this is a prototype, but the game needs a ton of polish before it can start showing its potential. I would love to see an alternate take on what Overcooked started, but right now it is just using the same mechanics. I could totally see you figuring that out and going forward with it however
[10/20]
Total Score: 46/100 [3 Stars]