Uhm let's see, I don't know where to start...
My favorite boy? Well damn, I liked them all in different ways.
Nightowl is that kid I wanna root for and support (not to mention, I vibe with him about staying up), Quest is that guy who's plain sweet and pleasant to be with, and Toasty is... well, I just like boys with long hair ok? I also liked his voice. He's also cute-awkward. And while I don't play XIV, I'd totally play with him (as long as he pays for my sub =w=).
Buuut if I really gotta pick... I'd say Quest for his backstory. Idk, I'm just happy for him that he got back up after what happened to him. I also liked *SPOILER* how we get into chat with both Night and Toasty on his route. Somehow, I also liked his route's plotline with the 'troll' and I'm just... HAHA MOD POWERS GO. Wish we could have roasted that guy more >:D Lowkey wondering how the other boys would deal with it *SPOILER*
Anyway, I ended up binging the game and it's like 4:00am rn and I'm totally shaking hands with Night for this.
Also lemme just say that my little brother was watching me play Night's route and said he liked the (smug) teddybear in his room XD