I am waiting to hear back from Itch.io, the current level of dissatisfaction with the voting has left us with few options. The best avenue we have figured out is to conduct a revote. This time with the clearest of understandings of how the system works amongst all parties involved. Including Clickteam which will manually append their 40% weighted vote correctly at the end of the voting period.
Viewing post in Voting Results - Clickteam's Official Response
I am not going to be in a position to change how the voting system works on Itch.io. But not that everyone understands that portion is a popularity contest, everyone can modify there game on the voting. get out the network your game. Plus the revote will allow us to properly assess our 40% weighted vote at Clickteam.